Tend to agree here but its also possible the crack's beginnings were deeper down and didn't hit the surface till later. Any custom maker i've ever dealt with would repair/replace no questions asked. Its obvious the cue hasn't been abused. Instead of keeping a customer they told the guy to pound sand. Pretty shitty service for someone that sees themselves as an 'industry leader'. Yeah right.So was this very obviously visible crack on the butt there when you first took possession of the cue? Did you not closely inspect the cue when you first got it? It doesn’t sound like you discovered the crack and returned it immediately and I’m just curious why not?