First of all, let me say that I have not been watching the current tournament, but I did spend part of last week watching the Accu-Stats Make It Happen 14.1 event. I am a huge 14.1 fan. About the only pool I watch is one-pocket, 14.1, and bank pool when the game is down to one or two balls on the table. As soon as the players start shooting the balls in numerical order, my interest wanes.
1. What many people see as a disadvantage in straight pool, I see as an attraction. I refer to the fact that at any time, including the break, one player is in danger of never getting to the table again, or even at all. Straight pool is sudden death from the lag. Who doesn’t like sudden death? I watch the eighth and ninth innings of baseball games on TV, not the first three.
2. You want slightly larger pockets for straight pool so that there can be high runs because of what I said in #1.
3. In the old days (and, Oldzilla, if you were only three years old in 1954 you are a mere child), but, as I was saying, in the old days players would frequently shoot a ball from the rack area up into one of the two top corner pockets. Mosconi did it all the time. That frequently simplified a rack so that the players could play stop ball position to the key ball and break ball. No one does it now because the pockets are so tight. The result is that many racks have to be played out with fairly complex patterns with a good deal of movement of the cue ball.
4. Straight pool on a 5 x 10 looks different. Rarely can you play stop ball position or just nip a cue ball to tip it into position. You have to roll into position much more often than on a 4.5 x 9.
5. I’m not sure what we see played right now should even be called 14.1. I haven’t seen how the Champion cloth plays, but on the Simonis close-to-billiard-speed cloth that the game is now played on, the racks open much more than they used to. Only five or six times in my life, playing for fun, have I tried to do what Thorsten Hohmann commonly does when he has a break shot on which he is using draw: draw the cue ball off the rack all the way up to the cushion at the head of the table and bounce it off that cushion back to the middle of the table with the balls going all over creation. As Jack Colavita used to say, the LAST THING you want in straight pool is a break that sends the balls all over the table.
6. I’m all for a time limit in pool, but it should not be “zero-tolerance” (administrative speak for “I have a brain but I’m not going to use it.”) The referee should be able to declare that certain situations in pool, and especially straight pool and one-pocket, are peculiarly strategic and therefore the time limit will be either suspended entirely or greatly extended. The shot after the break and safety battles would be such situations. I remember seeing a straight pool match between Crane and Lassiter in which they probably had a ball-per-inning average of about 5 or 6, but the match was extraordinarily exciting. Safety battles can be fun too!
7. What is this thing with cleaning the balls? Is something wrong with the chalk?