Ha ha Rick, thank you!...
You're right when you spoke about stroke: cue and shaft you need depends of your stroke, if you have not a good one your cue is supposed to help you to put more english and if you have a good one, your cue is supposed helping to control your stroke.
In carom games stroke control is very very important because you need to control your aim on the object ball and your stroke to touch the third ball and by the way controlling where the three balls will stop... The object ball will not disappear in a pocket!! In any case I don't want to say that pool is easier than carom because it is not... but being a strong carom player does not require same qualities than being a strong pool player.
After that in carom when you play straight rail with small shots and a lot of massé shots you need to have heavy shafts but not too stiff, when you play 3c your shaft is never too stiff especially if you play international tournaments with brand new balls and clothes: your ball is more sliding on the table that rolling! In those conditions you need maximum control.
Last (not really but for this post) shaft (and cue) characteristics you need depends of your game, we can say there is too family, too school: Belgian and rest of the world (including France)
On most familiar 3 cushion points Belgian players used to play more with balls rejects (between your ball and object ball) with zero (or near zero) English, that way balls reactions especially when touching rails are very similar and easy to imagine. Easier with stiff shaft.
French and other players are more prone to play with maximum english and more dynamic strokes. Easier with more flexible shaft.
Those too school have the same goal: finding the easier way to imagine where the 3 balls are going to be after the stroke.
Zero english: I know what happens: easier
Maxi english: I know what happens: easier
But between zero and maximum it is too difficult: one tip of english? 2 tips? Results will depends of each player, of balls, of table, of cue, etc...
How you can measure english? One inch of english? One liter? One oz? Too difficult!... That's why it is zero (close to zero) or maxi...
To make good shafts, wood is important depending of the game you play but most important is taper, right taper with right wood and it is perfect.
I see. So those big thick masse cues you see the trick shot guys use are not good for a straight rail player because you need more feel from the shaft when you make the ball dance around another ball.
That's what I thought but I never trained or practiced straight rail. Here in the US most people don't understand the point of it. I did not either until I saw you do some things that were magic keeping those 3 balls together and scoring huge numbers.
Thanks for the point of clarification my friend.
Rick