Ivory use & Africa Lession

Fatboy

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Just to settel some minds this topic has come up again, I have spent a lot of time in Africa and worked in the Safari industry photographic & hunting-for just over 7 years. I have friends who have been in the business for 40 years 3 generations-thats who I work with, I go to Africa every year for a month or two at a time, i communicate with them all the time, I just wanted to clairfy a few things, and inform people who havent been to africa or understand what is really going on there, the information we get here on TV, is way off base, just like people who think that all pool players are drunks etc, they have all these preconcieved notions and never been to a pool room. I've been to Africa many time and want to share this:


(I was responding to a post in a long thread)you are right the African elephants will kill you in a big hurry, especially cows, tuskless(recessive genitic trait) are the meanest of them all or when they have calfs(cute little guys). The elephant populations are at record levels since game counts started over 100 years ago, killing endangered animals or killing elephants in areas where there are small endangered populations of elephants(not to many areas) is worse than wrong, its unconsienciable(SP?), but killing elephants where there are strong populations that will renew themselfs at the rate they are being harvested is ok, killing elephants to the extent your reducing the size of the heards is no good either, so it depends on the circumstances, I have killed elephants and will again. I wouldnt ever shoot a rhino, infact it is LEGAL to shoot and kill rhino and ivory poachers in most countrys-Zimbabwe etc.


The $$ that I pay or anyone who sport hunts any animal goes into the Parks(like the game wardens here) to control the poachers, do game counts and define quotas every year to insure the groewth and managment of ALL animals. Hunting is the largest source of $$ for most southern african countrys thus they protect the game to insure their oun future.

All the animals that are killed in africa are eaten, no protein goes to waste in Africa, hell they eat the lungs of animals, all the hides, bones etc are used or turned into carvings etc, Ivory is just a small % of what is used, when an dead elephant is found the Ivory is measured, weighed, and the area is recorded, there are wearhouses of tusks, they used to burn them when they had no-more room, now they got smart and sell most of it to china.

Its a industry that is misunderstood by 99% of Americans because of all the bogus charitys raising $$$ under the pretence that they are going to save the world and all the animals in it, meanwhile they are living lavishly on ill gotten gains, the Christains who go to Africa and build schools etc. are accepted by the people who live in the bush with open arms because they get cloths and food, when the Christians leave they vacate the buildings they build and go back to their huts-I have plenty of pics, they perfer their huts to proper buildings, in the urban areas its different its like it is here just not as nice, but bushmen are bushmen,

thats the end of my Africa lession, but dont worrie about Ivory and killing elephants. its ok.
__________________
 
Last edited:
i will be glad to answer any questions about africa anyone has.

i dont want to get into an ethical debate about killing animals, i like meat, i dont want to destroy nature, i will not commit any crimes against animals or make them suffer,

this thread is to inform poeple about africa and clear up any misconceptions, if I dont have an answer to a question i'll be honest because I dont know everything, most of my knowlege is about Zimbabwe. i hope it will be consrtuctive

it does relate to pool because we do use ivory thus it is approiate here, i want to contribute what I canto this forum, we have alot of great people/players here and I have a high respect fr everyone here, i hope others feel the same about me, glad that some thought my Efren thread was funny.
 
I can agree with most of what Fatboy has said. I used to hunt, but don't anymore. In PA, the $ from a hunter's license pays for the conservation of our animals. When an area becomes over populated with certain animals, they devastate the area and the food supplies. Population must b controlled to permit the animals to live and prosper in good health. No one wants to c over population cause them starve to death or become diseased and suffer a slo painful death. If an animal must b killed, none of it should go to waste.

If an elephant must b killed, nothing should go to waste. The tusks should not b burned. They should b sold by the proper authorities with a letter showing the ivory was obtained legally, and the $ used to help animals and their surroundings.

Charlie
 
Fatboy said:
i will be glad to answer any questions about africa anyone has.

i dont want to get into an ethical debate about killing animals, i like meat, i dont want to destroy nature, i will not commit any crimes against animals or make them suffer,

this thread is to inform poeple about africa and clear up any misconceptions, if I dont have an answer to a question i'll be honest because I dont know everything, most of my knowlege is about Zimbabwe. i hope it will be consrtuctive

it does relate to pool because we do use ivory thus it is approiate here, i want to contribute what I canto this forum, we have alot of great people/players here and I have a high respect fr everyone here, i hope others feel the same about me, glad that some thought my Efren thread was funny.


Off topic a little, but i just watched Blood Diamond. Did you ever see anything like that while you were over there?

If you haven't seen the movie or don't know what it is about my bad.
 
I have posted this in the other post and I will post here again

I happened to watch "UNFORGETTABLE ELEPHANTS" on PBS at a friend's house earlier and I would highly recommend it to everyone.

http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/index.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video2.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video3.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/31/a...tml?ex=1176436800&en=6cb584ef4fe8ad0e&ei=5070

After deeply moved by the show, I told myself I will never buy a product with Ivory in it
and I would urge my friends to do the same.



Let's have compassion and be just a little more thoughtful for other life forms. Let the desire go away.

Make peace with the world, with ourselves, for the future.



I will not be angry with your decisions, but I will feel sad for the animals who have their own quiet lives and never mean to harm us.
 
i agree destroying nature is unacceptable and inexcusable, asian elephants are wonderful animals and I wouldnt hurt them, different parts of the world have different cultures and imposing our western views elsewhere is no good either. respect Africas culture too, many people get killed by hippos every year, then crocks , elephants are 3rd on the list followed by lions.
 
true there is still illegal killing

cuetable said:
I have posted this in the other post and I will post here again

I happened to watch "UNFORGETTABLE ELEPHANTS" on PBS at a friend's house earlier and I would highly recommend it to everyone.

http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/index.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video2.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video3.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/31/a...tml?ex=1176436800&en=6cb584ef4fe8ad0e&ei=5070

After deeply moved by the show, I told myself I will never buy a product with Ivory in it
and I would urge my friends to do the same.



Let's have compassion and be just a little more thoughtful for other life forms. Let the desire go away.

Make peace with the world, with ourselves, for the future.



I will not be angry with your decisions, but I will feel sad for the animals who have their own quiet lives and never mean to harm us.
just thankfully not to the extent of the old days when everyone turned a blin d eye to the issues in africa in general and the slaughter of these magnificent beast particularly !:(
 
cuetable said:
I have posted this in the other post and I will post here again

I happened to watch "UNFORGETTABLE ELEPHANTS" on PBS at a friend's house earlier and I would highly recommend it to everyone.

http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/index.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video2.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video3.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/31/a...tml?ex=1176436800&en=6cb584ef4fe8ad0e&ei=5070

After deeply moved by the show, I told myself I will never buy a product with Ivory in it
and I would urge my friends to do the same.



Let's have compassion and be just a little more thoughtful for other life forms. Let the desire go away.

Make peace with the world, with ourselves, for the future.



I will not be angry with your decisions, but I will feel sad for the animals who have their own quiet lives and never mean to harm us.


What about the poor souls who are killed before they have ever had a chance to live? We should have the same or even more awareness and compassion for them.
 
cuetable said:
I have posted this in the other post and I will post here again

I happened to watch "UNFORGETTABLE ELEPHANTS" on PBS at a friend's house earlier and I would highly recommend it to everyone.

http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/index.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video2.html
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/unforgettable/video3.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/31/a...tml?ex=1176436800&en=6cb584ef4fe8ad0e&ei=5070

After deeply moved by the show, I told myself I will never buy a product with Ivory in it
and I would urge my friends to do the same.



Let's have compassion and be just a little more thoughtful for other life forms. Let the desire go away.

Make peace with the world, with ourselves, for the future.



I will not be angry with your decisions, but I will feel sad for the animals who have their own quiet lives and never mean to harm us.

Tap...Tap...Tap. I wish I had said that. I'd be proud of me.
 
Long & Informative Post RE: Ivory

The following is a post that was made on RSB, years ago by Thomas Wayne in response to a woman (Laura) decrying the use of ivory in cues. I posted this in the original thread, but it seems to have been overlooked in the shuffle. I think it's one of the best posts ever about this topic.

THINGS YOU DON’T KNOW ABOUT ELEPHANTS AND THEIR IVORY:
__________________________________________________ ____________
Elephants are herbivores, surviving on abrasive plant matter available in their natural habitat. In the process of chewing this plant matter, the elephant tends to wear out its teeth at a rather rapid rate. While a good set of teeth might last us 60 years or more, the elephant goes through a set of teeth in 6 - 10 years. When these teeth are worn out, they are replaced by a new set, allowing for a ‘fresh start’. But there is a limit. Elephants have the capacity for only SIX sets of teeth. When the last set wears out, the elephant, by this time large and masterful, dies a slow and unpleasant death by starvation. Period.

Elephants have no natural enemies; disease and starvation are the only limitations to their continued success in the wild. For this reason, a well protected herd can grow quite rapidly, in fact TOO rapidly for most habitats.

Elephants compete with man for land. As the human populations of the African countries grow, the elephants have increasingly less space to call home. With no commercial value currently attached to the elephant herds, there is little incentive for the local inhabitants to preserve this majestic ‘land hog’.

Elephant Ivory has NEVER sold for more in the United States than it does right now; $110 per pound is about the maximum one has to pay for top quality tusks. By contrast, the Asian countries have ALWAYS been willing to pay premium prices, as high as $200 or more, for the same ivory. This ivory is used for, among other things, the personal "name chops" with which these cultures like to "sign" (ink stamp) their names, hence the term. Because they often cut the ivory into such small pieces, aging and dryness is not so important to them. Logistically, it is much easier to smuggle poached ivory into the Asian countries than to the U.S.; I am unaware of any case of elephant ivory being smuggled into THIS country.
WHO HAS BANNED THE INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN IVORY?

The international trade in wildlife is regulated by the Convention on the International Trade in Endangered Species (C.I.T.E.S.). Formed in 1973, this multinational (more than 100 countries) division of the UN, housed in Switzerland, meets every two years to determine guidelines for governing the protection of endangered species. In 1990, C.I.T.E.S. officially changed the status of the African elephant from ‘Appendix 2’ (protected/threatened) to ‘Appendix 1’ (endangered). This change banned all international trade in elephant ivory, though the United States had been under a self-imposed ban since 1989.

EVERBODY LOVES ELEPHANTS, SO WHAT COULD BE WRONG WITH BANNING COMMERCIAL TRADE IN ELEPHANT IVORY?

Unfortunately for the elephant, the ban has hurt more than it has helped. When the president of Kenya (Daniel arap Moi) burned a large pile of elephant tusks on international television in 1989, he set fire to a movement for a worldwide ivory ban directed at stopping poaching. While this was fine for the countries of East Africa, where poaching actually WAS a problem, it has spelled disaster for the elephants of southern Africa. Three countries in particular - Zimbabwe, South Africa, and Botswana - had, for over 20 years, successfully managed to INCREASE the size of their herds through careful game management.

Remember the leading causes for elephant deaths: disease and starvation? In a well managed herd, these animals are culled (killed and removed from the herd) in order to allow the rest of the herd to thrive. In fact, most of the news footage of "wanton elephant slaughter by poachers" seen on ‘nature shows’ around the time of the ban was actually film of government-managed herd thinning programs. Not coincidentally, after culling, the commercially desirable ivory, hides and meat are then sold on the open market. Or at least they WERE sold, until the ban took effect. The successful game management programs of these exemplary countries were paid for, in abundance, through the sale of salvaged elephant products. By 1992, for example, Zimbabwe had culled more than 44,000 elephants over a 25 year period, yet their herds continued to increase in numbers. South Africa and Botswana have similar tracks records. In fact, by 1992 there were more than 650,000 elephants in the wild! Never before in history has a species with such huge numbers been labeled "endangered".

Now, the problem is land. The unchecked growth of elephant herds has collided squarely with the humans’ growing need for living space. With this conflict, the ability of these countries to manage their herds has all but evaporated. Botswana’s planned schedule of limiting its elephant population at about 55,000 has become financially impossible. The success of any game management plan hinges on its finances. It is very hard to justify using continually larger tracts of land to house an abundant species that isn’t even allowed to pay for its own keep. And you can just about forget about defending against poachers. Since poachers are most generally shot to death on sight, they tend to fight back pretty ferociously. It’s kind of hard to find game officers willing to risk their lives battling heavily armed ivory thieves for minimum wage!

SO, WHAT THE HELL AM I SAYING HERE, ANYWAY?

What I am saying here is, Laura - with all due respect - your plea for cuemakers to stop using ivory, while clearly quite passionate is, in a word: misguided. African elephants are not only NOT in danger of extinction, at this point they are actually suffering from OVER-population. Meanwhile, poaching is under control, but not for much longer. These African countries are running out of resources, and when something finally has to give, it’s going to be the elephants. Without the income from salvaged elephant products, these successful game management programs are doomed. It’s just a matter of time.

Your suggestion that "the US has recently lifted an ivory embargo against Japan" is way off base. In fact, C.I.T.E.S. has just recently approved (the U.S. opposed this) a ONE-TIME bulk sale of elephant ivory to Japan to help satisfy that market demand and to defray southern African game management expenses. This ivory is from the culled stockpiles that countries like Zimbabwe have collected and stored since the ban was imposed. The amount allowed was significantly smaller than the Southern African Centre for Ivory Marketing (SACIM) had requested. This highly controlled and greatly limited trade agreement, while merely a ‘drop in the bucket’, has been hailed by the southern African conservationists as a first step in the right direction.

As for your statement that: "Using Ivory encourages poaching", well, allow me to respectfully disagree:

Ivory can be found in the finest of all art forms, both ancient and modern. In a multitude of examples throughout history, it has created the greatest impact of any material used. It is really only a recent fad to look at ivory as a negative thing. This frenzied ‘knee-jerk’ reaction to sensationalistic journalism - at its worst - has resulted in a political climate wherein the African elephant might finally be destroyed by the very forces that would seek to "save" it. Your argument that "using [ancient, legal] ivory encourages poaching" is, at best, naive. It presupposes that the entire population of the earth can be persuaded by a few idealistic ‘tree-huggers’. Why do you think synthetic ferrule materials are made ivory colored? One of the more popular materials for this purpose is even called "Ivorine 3"! Laura, are your ferrules a non-ivory color (say black phenolic, for example)? No? Well, aren’t you worried that you’ll help feed the public desire for ivory with your look-alike substitute? :-] People want ivory. It’s that simple. The solution to protecting the elephant is to REGULATE ivory use, not ban it. In that way, the elephant can fund (in excess) its own survival. But without the regulated sale of salvaged ivory, the elephant may ultimately be doomed.

As for cuemakers, you can sleep peacefully on that issue. Any cuemaker foolish enough to use fresh ("green") ivory in a cue will get what he so richly deserves. As a general rule, if I can’t document that a tusk was taken (at a minimum) BEFORE I was born, I won’t buy it.

If you REALLY want to do something to ‘save’ the elephant, perhaps you’d be willing to send large sums of money to some of these south African countries to help fund their game management programs. I’ll be happy to provide you with the addresses...

Thomas Wayne
 
Back
Top