I'm gonna pull out the ladle one more time and stir the pot.... as I find this thread pretty entertaining.:wink: And besides, Cuetip is getting free exposure by bumping....
I really wish it hadn't turned into a brass ferrules are better thing though, which is all opinion and personal preference. (Feel free to debate but in a new thread please)
I really like Wity's car analogy. Sure, common sense suggests that changing the radio should not change the car. However, by your own admission and others changing the ferrule changed the feel of the stroke. Softer hit, less deflection etc. So it's like installing say a racing suspension. Now if it was a Ford Pinto that might be a good thing.
However, the name John Parris caries a price premium (for whatever reason) A better analogy would be a '67 Mustang. Would that be worth more with the original factory suspension or with a new sport tuned suspension? I bet everybody can answer that question!
How about if that suspension was installed by Joe Sixpack, rather than a certified Ford Mechanic? Do you trust that the wheels won't come off on the next speed bump?
I'm not saying the Cuetip doesn't know his craft. I'm sure he does, very few people can replace a ferrule themselves! But it's not attached to John Parris name nor warranty (nor price premium).
Everybody telling us to leave the thread alone didn't read that there were legitimate questions. How much does such a cue go for? What's up with the ferrule? What is a reasonable offer? According to cuetip himself he will accept any reasonable offer over $600. See here ->
http://www.thesnookerforum.com/board/showthread.php?t=16752
It is human nature to value something more than what the market value truly is, because you own it; it was yours. Nor is it important what you personally paid for it and would like to recoup that investment. You can buy a new JP of his website for $376, or you can buy this one (or keep looking). $250 is a fair price, considering the crack in the butt (that really is damage no matter how you spin it) and the replaced ferrule. Wity's 200 quid is in the same price range.
Thus ends the service announcement to fellow snooker sub-forum members.