If you think all else is equal, you should judge your choice based on the style you prefer. Also, desired shaft would also be a factor.
Personally, I prefer nice looking wood, either highly figured merry widow or old style 4 point cues, veneers or not. Meucci has a style that differs for me, for the most part.
If you do go with schmelke, ask for a standard pin and standard thickness at the joint to maximize your compatibility for aftermarket shafts. 3/8-10 is a good choice.
Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk