I seriously doubt that yourself, or anyone else would be able to tell the difference between a small pad and without.
The only time that I will use a pad is when I install a break tip. Then I use an OB carbon pad on most. Fiber on some.
When changing a Phenolic tip to non phenolic, I will face off and leave a tiny phenolic pad on the ferrule.
That and if you are trying to protect an ivory ferrule or making the tip of your cue pretty with a blue or red one.
A buck a piece for an acrylic pad. Ha. You can get many from a CD disc.
I just made a note to self. Next time at Canadian Tire, buy a Forstner bit.
I have found that most window shops also keep in stock certain thicknesses of Acrylic, or whatever clear plastic they may use as a window covering. They have tons of scrap and will probably give out a handful for a buck.
HH7, I know yer a good guy but, I think that you are over thinking this tip pad thing way too much. If your heart is bent on it, just put one on and see what you think.
You can buy a bunch from Royce at OB, a pack of 50, Black, Blue and Red for a couple of dollars from Atlas Supply.
Prather and Schmelke probably have some too. Personally, if going for the added strength part, I would just get some from OB.
You absolutely can't bend those little buggers in half. And the next tip change, no need change the pad, just rough it a bit and add another tip. The same with a plain fiber pad. Those are good for a couple of tip changes or more.
In fact, I have to buy some more from OB anyway, and I am way over stocked on Black fiber. PM me and tell me how many you'd like and I will put them in an envelope for you. I can send you one or 2 carbon and a half dozen or ten fiber ones.