PDA

View Full Version : Poll: Match between (Rodney, Corey, Sky, Oscar, Billy) and Karen: your guess


mikepage
08-14-2017, 11:59 AM
Imagine a set between Karen Corr and whoever you think is best between Rodney Morris, Corey Deuel, Sky Woodward, Oscar Dominguez and Billy Thorpe

Set is best of 5, races to 11 matches, with the equipment and rules of the US Open

But Karen may get a spot.

Using your best judgment, what spot makes the Set as close as possible, --so that YOU would struggle with which way to call it?

Karen gets 0 games: match is 11 to 11
Karen gets 1 game: match is 11 to 10
Karen gets 2 games: match is 11 to 9
Karen gets 3 games: match is 11 to 8
Karen gets 4 games: match is 11 to 7
Karen gets 5 games: match is 11 to 6
Karen gets 6 games: match is 11 to 5
Karen gets 7 games: match is 11 to 4
other

Coop1701
08-14-2017, 12:01 PM
Imagine a set between Karen Corr and whoever you think is best between Rodney Morris, Corey Deuel, Sky Woodward, Oscar Dominguez and Billy Thorpe

Set is best of 5, races to 11 matches, with the equipment and rules of the US Open

But Karen may get a spot.

Using your best judgment, what spot makes the Set as close as possible, --so that YOU would struggle with which way to call it?

Karen gets 0 games: match is 11 to 11
Karen gets 1 game: match is 11 to 10
Karen gets 2 games: match is 11 to 9
Karen gets 3 games: match is 11 to 8
Karen gets 4 games: match is 11 to 7
Karen gets 5 games: match is 11 to 6
Karen gets 6 games: match is 11 to 5
Karen gets 7 games: match is 11 to 4
other


2 Games... 11 to 9

watchez
08-14-2017, 03:56 PM
What are US Open rules ---

who racks?
winner break?
9 on the spot?

AtLarge
08-14-2017, 05:09 PM
What are US Open rules ---

who racks?
winner break?
9 on the spot?

breaker
yes
yes

http://forums.azbilliards.com/showpost.php?p=5919386&postcount=1

mikepage
08-15-2017, 04:53 AM
Imagine a set between Karen Corr and whoever you think is best between Rodney Morris, Corey Deuel, Sky Woodward, Oscar Dominguez and Billy Thorpe

Set is best of 5, races to 11 matches, with the equipment and rules of the US Open

But Karen may get a spot.

Using your best judgment, what spot makes the Set as close as possible, --so that YOU would struggle with which way to call it?

Karen gets 0 games: match is 11 to 11
Karen gets 1 game: match is 11 to 10
Karen gets 2 games: match is 11 to 9
Karen gets 3 games: match is 11 to 8
Karen gets 4 games: match is 11 to 7
Karen gets 5 games: match is 11 to 6
Karen gets 6 games: match is 11 to 5
Karen gets 7 games: match is 11 to 4
other


Bumping this to get a few more responses

GideonF
08-15-2017, 06:01 AM
I would also say 2 games.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Bob Jewett
08-15-2017, 07:02 AM
I would say that against the strongest of those, 3 games, but against the weakest, 2 games.

westcoast
08-15-2017, 10:35 AM
I would say that against the strongest of those, 3 games, but against the weakest, 2 games.

I agree- these players aren't exactly equal- Morris and Oscar are probably better than the rest. I think Corr would really test Corey, Sky, and Thorpe with just a minor spot

TATE
08-15-2017, 10:44 AM
Using Rodney, Oscar and Sky as the benchmark, if it were 4 games on the wire in a race to 11, I might consider her. 3 games I would take the guys, especially winner breaks.

This is no knock on Karen. She is a champion. But playing these guys would be a bit more heat than she usually gets.

By the way Mike, this is a great poll. I am interested in the results - I am mainly interested in how Fargorate calculates the match. I have nothing but respect for the Fargorate system.

mikepage
08-15-2017, 10:45 AM
I agree- these players aren't exactly equal- Morris and Oscar are probably better than the rest. I think Corr would really test Corey, Sky, and Thorpe with just a minor spot

I'm going for a wild guess here:

You like Disneyland better than Disneyworld...

Nick B
08-15-2017, 10:52 AM
3 and I take the boys. 4 is my tipping point. The problem is with 3 if she happens to win the first game she is a big favorite from there.

AtLarge
08-15-2017, 11:31 AM
I'm in the 3 camp.

alstl
08-15-2017, 12:14 PM
She would probably get a spot but I remember a couple years ago she beat Earl to advance to the finals and then lost to Shaw.

On a good day she could beat any of the guys on your list even but she probably does get a spot. I'm not sure how much snooker or black ball she plays but I wouldn't be surprised if she is even in both of those games.

westcoast
08-15-2017, 12:15 PM
I'm going for a wild guess here:

You like Disneyland better than Disneyworld...

I'm not sure I get the joke- you mean these guys are all fairly similar in talent and that there is no need to split hairs. If so, you're probably right :)

SpinDoctor
08-15-2017, 12:19 PM
I picked 2 games, might swing as much as 3 but anything more than that and I can't possibly see KC losing in that format.

9andout
08-15-2017, 02:00 PM
I voted other.
Karen vs. Big Ko. Even! Been done though.;)

GideonF
08-15-2017, 11:47 PM
I picked 2 games, might swing as much as 3 but anything more than that and I can't possibly see KC losing in that format.



Well, I certainly can see her losing with 4 or 5 games against say Rodney in winner breaks. He might run a five pack and a 6 pack and smoke her. He might do that to anyone.

I said 2 earlier, but if is best of 5 sets and the best of the players listed, I think 3 may be better.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk