And your comments above say a lot about you and nothing about him. It says that you are absolutely clueless about the fact that hit and playability are completely subjective personal preference things that will vary substantially between players and there is no "right" and "wrong" to that, just perhaps a right or wrong for you and a right or wrong for him and a right or wrong for me which may all be very different. If you actually understood that fact you would have never felt the need to try to put down his personal preferences with such obviously dumb comments.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion and if you publicly express it, you should be prepared for opposing views.
When you take the time to elaborate why you feel that way, usually the reception by others tends to be positive.
Not always but it shows you actually thought about it before writing it. And sometimes you don’t get the reaction
you expected or hoped for. But that is how public forums function. All I did was inject some reality into the thread.
Do a national poll….Tim Scruggs and Southwest cues are rated very highly by the vast majority of pool players that
own cues costing more than a few hundred dollars. Nothing wrong with inexpensive cues because they do the very
same thing as a rare Gus Szamboti cue does. And the cue doesn’t make the person a better pool player either. It
does encourage you to try harder or to commit more to playing better but that doesn’t apply to everyone. Just like
expressing the opinion that that some cues made by great names disappointed you, it obviously doesn’t apply to
everyone. The catch is that most pool players would enjoy and celebrate owning a cue made by Tim Scruggs or SW.
I merely reminded the OP his opinion was not shared, nor supported, by the majority of knowledgeable pool players.