I've played with both piloted and flat faced ivory jointed cues. The hit is totally different. It seems to me that piloted creates a lot more vibration while flat faced is, like everyone else said, very stiff. Even with a LD shaft on my piloted cue, the vibration was crazy, as if the shaft was flexing entirely too much. I liked the different set-ups for different shots that I needed to make but there were also negative aspects that I did not like for others. IMHO, go with wood to wood, the hit is outstanding and the cue ball control is great. I have a wood to wood Jacoby, which is actually for sale (
http://forums.azbilliards.com/showthread.php?t=209566) and it plays like a monster. You can feel every shot as if the cue were part of your hand/arm. I'm sure you're going to ask me why I am selling it and it's because it is just too flashy of a cue for me (thats all).