I really don't have a dog in this fight either. We don't use ivory in anything we make, and I've personally only used it a very few times, quite long ago. And, of course, it was all pre-ban ivory.
I do find this topic very interesting though, and of course, I want elephants to live peacefully and not be slaughtered for their tusks. But, a lot of what we hear seems to be really hyped up so I'm not so sure I believe it all.
Here's a brief summary of some things I've picked up from what I believe to be good sources. My wording may not be exactly correct, but it's what I recall from several conversations and things I've read.
Ivory suitable for use in cues has to be pretty old and well seasoned or it will split and crack.
There are hundreds or maybe even thousands of tons of "Natural Fall" ivory every year. "Natural Fall" ivory is ivory that naturally falls to ground. It comes from natural death due to old age or sickness. It comes from elephants killed because they are attacking villages or people. It comes from elephants culled from the heard to control populations in areas that have an over population of elephants. I don't know how much is currently stock piled but the estimates are huge.
Countries that deal with poaching fall into 2 different categories, those who are successful at managing their elephant populations, and those that aren't. The ones who are successful do so by using the money they get from "Natural Fall" elephant ivory to hire professional military type personnel to fight the poachers. Those who don't sell that ivory and have very small budgets are over run with poachers.
It seems pretty clear that the countries who don't follow CITES regulations and use the income from their ivory have growing, and often over populated, elephant herds.
In our world today, there are so many "organizations" out there who's apparent goals are to protect this or that. I've heard that one of these "Protect the Elephants" organizations had raised an extremely large amount of money. The officers of this organization are supposedly making huge salaries. But, if you took the amount of money this organization already has, you could put armed guards on every elephant herd in Africa for many many years.
As I said, we don't use ivory and don't have any plans to do so either. Elephants are beautiful majestic creatures and I am all for the fight against the needless killing of them. I do, however, feel that not everyone who claims to be fighting for the elephants is actually fighting for the elephants. There's just too much money and politics involved.
Royce