Yes, in my books, Buddy Hall was the best nine ball pattern player of all time.
I have seen just two players since that were even mentionable in the same breath as nine ball pattern players and they'd be Ralf Souquet and Wu Jiaqing, but neither is Buddy's equal.
Buddy is remembered as an all-time great as he should be, but needs to be remembered for even more. He is, to me, "the father of nine ball position play."
Happy birthday to a true legend.
Happy birthday to the Rifleman, to me the greatest 9 ball player who ever lived.
There are too many of his career highlights to list, but my personal favorite was the time in Dayton in 1974, during the runup to Joe Burns' tournament (which Buddy won), when he and Mike Siegel were each running one rack after the other, neither of them missing a ball.
The punch line is that Buddy was playing lefthanded while Siegel was playing righthanded. There was no way on Earth that someone who didn't know they were playing with the "wrong" hand ever would have known the difference.
Couldn't agree more, Stu about Buddy being the father. But I would say Earl as "same breath". And really? For me? *Only* Earl... of course, meaning Earl at 18 to 28 or so....
As a pattern player? No way does Earl merit a mention. Yes, Earl was a better overall player than Buddy, but his break, his shot-making skills and his powerful stroke were the difference. His pattern play was good in terms of cinching the right side of the next ball, but his angle management wasn't as good as the most elite which is why he often wasn't as close to the object ball as the others. It is in this respect that Buddy outshone them all.
Happy birthday, Buddy
Maybe the finest strokes that ever moved a cue
On the Earl/Buddy comparison
Earl’s accuracy and power got him out of a lot of trouble
...a ten year old could’ve made the ball off Buddy’s position
For me, Earl was always showing how great he was
Buddy was always showing how great the game is...like Steve Davis
Happy birthday, Buddy
Maybe the finest strokes that ever moved a cue
On the Earl/Buddy comparison
Earl’s accuracy and power got him out of a lot of trouble
...a ten year old could’ve made the ball off Buddy’s position
For me, Earl was always showing how great he was
Buddy was always showing how great the game is...like Steve Davis
I don't normally disagree with you Stu, let alone multiple times in one post but, hey... always a first time. As in now...
I have to disagree that Earl was/is a better over-all player. I think Buddy is the better player. And I am ( as you know ) a HUGE Earl fan. And I'm well aware of his play in all games. Still, to me, Buddy ranks ahead. Not by much, probably. But Buddy is #1 with Earl #1B. And, as far as pattern-play goes, I disagree once again. I think Earl played ( 18 to 28 ) patterns in 9ball better than anyone EXCEPT Buddy. And of course, it's really a matter of opinion. One person's def of pattern play might be dif than someone else's.
Another guy who played the patterns better than Earl was Jim Rempe.
You may be right, though, it may be terminology. Position play and pattern play are not the same thing. Pattern play refers to a player's use of precise angle management to maximize the length of the position zone, and it is in this respect that Buddy is without equal in our game's history. Even Rempe was a bit less refined in this respect, and neither Wu nor Souquet has quite reached Buddy's level, either.
Earl was, indeed, a super-elite position player. I'm guessing this is just terminology, as we both know what we've seen over the years.
Another guy who played the patterns better than Earl was Jim Rempe.
You may be right, though, it may be terminology. Position play and pattern play are not the same thing. Pattern play refers to a player's use of precise angle management to maximize the length of the position zone, and it is in this respect that Buddy is without equal in our game's history. Even Rempe was a bit less refined in this respect, and neither Wu nor Souquet has quite reached Buddy's level, either.
Earl was, indeed, a super-elite position player. I'm guessing this is just terminology, as we both know what we've seen over the years.
LOVED watching Rempe play. Many, many times. Ref'd a few of his matches as well so had a front row seat for 'em!
Happy boithday to the rifleman. Always love sitting back and watching him on YouTube.
Quick, if you were to do another legends of pocket billiards event, which players get the invite?