Bank players please give me your thoughts on this. I'm used to breaking the rack like nineball. I recently played a guy and he used a onepocket type break.
Legal Break: A legal break requires you to strike the head ball first and drive at least one object ball past the side pockets. If your break is illegal, the opponent may either accept the table in position or require you to break again.
That's how it is in Derby so I'd have to say that would be the only way I'd be willing to gamble.....
I don't think I would ever soft break them anyway as I like my chances for 5 and outs if I am breaking good.. It's the 9ball rack so you are a favorite for making a ball on the break if you have worked on it......
Chris
Not a banker but... you have to be over 50% making a ball with that rack, I dunno why you'd give up that 'bird in hand'. If the other guy runs 5'n'out so easily you're scared to break the balls open, you probably should just switch to full rack or another game entirely.