Opinions on Rail rebuilders a can of worms?

Ron Padilla

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I am sure there are like most other things many opinions both good and bad! But would like to hear from some of you that have had it done, the Cost, Time involved, and the satisfaction of the work and I hope no one gets butt hurt ! I am still in the process of putting this GC 1 together and it has the original rubber and not sure it is bad, it did come out of a working pool hall the was closing in PA in the last couple of months! I have read where the Monarch rubber has and can live and last a long time but the wood is showing that it has been recovered a lot over time.

Thanks in advance
 

pt109

WO double hemlock
Silver Member
I would give that rubber a chance.....it can go a bit dead from not being hit....
...but hitting those rails can bring them back to life.
The main action tables in a lot of old rooms would have the best set of rails...
..due to frequent use.

...a rubber mallet from a body shop can speed up the process...just keep hitting the rails...
...no harder than a ball would hit them.

We got four GCIs in our room with original rubber...might be a half length to a full length
slower...but they still play well.
 

Ron Padilla

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I am still going to need something done on the wood though unless a whole bunch of wood putty would work?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

TATE

AzB Gold Mensch
Silver Member
No regrets here on new rails/cushions. Yes, it costs money but you get exactly the table you want for years of playing pleasure. Mine were custom and were Artemis both times.
 
Last edited:

pt109

WO double hemlock
Silver Member
No regrets here on new rails/cushions. Yes, it costs money but you get exactly the table you want for years of playing pleasure. Mine were custom and were Artemis both times.

The trouble with re-rubbering a GCI is that the rubber isn’t available any more...
...Brunswick SuperSpeed doesn’t play quite right on it...the fitting is quite costly...
...to have rubber that still doesn’t play as well.
 

Ron Padilla

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Is there any input on repairing what is there as I do agree about the original rubber, all though I cannot recall what I have had on some of the real old balk collender tables I have had but most likely the same as the GC1 and would like to keep it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

realkingcobra

Well-known member
Silver Member
Is there any input on repairing what is there as I do agree about the original rubber, all though I cannot recall what I have had on some of the real old balk collender tables I have had but most likely the same as the GC1 and would like to keep it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm still trying to figure out how a person can rebuild the split end grain of the rails without having to remove the cushions to do so.
 

realkingcobra

Well-known member
Silver Member
I would give that rubber a chance.....it can go a bit dead from not being hit....
...but hitting those rails can bring them back to life.
The main action tables in a lot of old rooms would have the best set of rails...
..due to frequent use.

...a rubber mallet from a body shop can speed up the process...just keep hitting the rails...
...no harder than a ball would hit them.

We got four GCIs in our room with original rubber...might be a half length to a full length
slower...but they still play well.

So the 4 GC1s still have the huge corner pockets as well as the split ends of the rails causing the cupping effect when pocketing balls?
 

pt109

WO double hemlock
Silver Member
So the 4 GC1s still have the huge corner pockets as well as the split ends of the rails causing the cupping effect when pocketing balls?

They will spit out balls with speed down the rails.
...gotta lot of experience with that for years...played on a lot with bad shims also.
Our Diamond 9-footers play much better....4,75 pockets.
 

JoeyInCali

Maker of Joey Bautista Cues
Silver Member
Good luck with that.
Better make sure the mech who does them is reputable .
If someone says he'll do it for $300, run.
 

FeelDaShot

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
FYI: I don't think Jerimy Chambers is doing rail work anymore. I hired him about 2 years ago to build completely new rails from scratch. He never did it and I eventually got sick of reminding him. I assume he is busy with other stuff. He seemed like a nice guy otherwise and his rail work looked very impressive. Hopefully he gets back into it sometime.
 
My apologies to you and all else who I didn't get back to about new rails. I rarely get on az anymore so private messages never got read. :sorry: I unfortunately lost my binder with a list of interested parties. please feel free to email me @ jerimychambers@yahoo.com I am still making rails and am running about 2-3 months out for delivery. I purchased some cnc machines (tooling them up now) to help me to get them produced a little faster. I am now also producing new aluminum trim for the gc 1,2,3 and 4 rails. I will try to get some update pics for anyone with interest. (FeelDaShot) please reach out to me again I will try to accommodate you for the frustration.
 

Lawnboy77

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I have no regrets having rails reworked, or in my case, new rails from Mark Gregory. Like RKC and the others have said, there is a lot more to good rails than a decent rebound. I'm just talking from personal experience with my Anniversary, but more than likely the OPs pocket angles, down angles are all wrong, not to mention the shelves are probably not in specs. In my case the figure 8 plate inserts required rework, the pocket casting mounting had the same issues, the cushion bevel was wrong for todays K-55 profile, and last but not least, the staple areas were toast. Some of that is probably due to years of commercial use, others maybe factory flaws. I don't know why anyone would want to correct all these issues, and then step backwards and put original 60 year old rubber back on the bevels? Makes no sense to me, even if the rubber were that much better back in those days, it's still 60 years old and there is no magic rubber out there with an effective service, or shelf life of 60 years.

There is nothing worse than playing on a table that rejects balls that were perfectly hit, and on the other side of the coin, accepts balls that it shouldn't. I don't mind playing on tight tables and missing shots, I just want equipment that meets, or exceeds BCA standards, and most importantly plays fair. Playing on a table that has crappy pockets is like playing basketball with an oversized, odd-shaped hoop, mounted to a flimsy backboard.
 
Top