I love the premise... Having stronger players critique your game is always valuable. I hope this is something the host continues to do. Listing your fargo rates is also is great idea. Provides substance to your comments.
Honestly... I think you guys were generous with your comments. The player has a decent stroke, granted. His position play is haphazard, and pattern play / table IQ is at square one imo. Of course you don't want to tear someone down too intensively, so I'm obviously not a good option as commentator for this channel.
I saw someone in the comments say that the player is around a strong 5 or a low 6 APA. We all know APA handicaps are driven by local talent pool, but I would say he is typical of a player who has focused solely on potting for a couple of years.
All in all... I hope you continue contributing to this channel. I didn't disagree with anything your group stated.
Well done