Thoughts on pool ,life and 5 inch pockets

jeephawk

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I appreciate your opinion and non aggressive delivery! I have said what I thought and I am sticking to it. I do understand what you are saying, but, I don't think that is the result of the angle/light. The left leg looks much more light brown and the other looks more reddish brown. As I mentioned earlier in the thread, I think one was re-veneered and the other not, the left one is the suspect, right one original. I will say without more pics, hard to say anything 100%. There is a way to prove this, I mentioned that as well. I doubt he will prove anything.

Dealing with the picture at hand, there is no doubt the rails are not even close to a match to either of the legs at all. As I also mentioned, the stain used on the rails is not going to be the same for the legs because of the woods being so drastically different. Brazilian Rosewood darkens up REALLY fast when you stain it and people who have worked with it know this.

Trent from Toledo

Just a thought and no expert here for sure. Seem to be a lot of differences of opinion on here (and NOT trying to take this in any other direction) about old Brunswicks and restoration and just glad there are folks that are invested in keeping them "alive" so to speak, wherever there point of view is coming from.
 

mchnhed

I Came, I Shot, I Choked
Silver Member
Millennnial???????????? Are you insane? Quit playing judge/moderator. I don't want/need your opinion on my actions. You know how to find stuff on here so don't act like you need you hand held. Really do without your snide little comments.
Sorry, I quess you a Gen Z’er?

BTW....As Far As Snide Remarks Go....PCTKB
 

Attachments

  • 03EC720D-603A-4B74-8614-A1A68B934A14.jpeg
    03EC720D-603A-4B74-8614-A1A68B934A14.jpeg
    46.2 KB · Views: 180

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
Tight pockets are a progression of the game. Things change over time as you know. The pro cut pocket is what many league players play on and obviously the pro's do to.

Right on, Trent.

Every sport goes through this as the equipment and players improve. Golf and American football offer two good examples.

Golf
Championship golf courses set up for pro events tended to be about 6,800 yards forty years ago. With the advances in equipment and the increase in the number of good players, such courses today are about 7,200 years. The old setups were not long enough to properly challenge the world's best players.

American football
Kickoffs at either the beginning of the game or after a team scored were executed form the 40 yard line in the 1970's and these kickoffs were frequently returned as they didn't reach the end zone. As kickers became more skillful, however, the kickoff was moved back to the 35 yard line, avoiding a decline in returnable kickoffs.

In golf, American football, and also pool, it is recognized that the game must keep pace with the improvements in both equipment and players. Pool is still a runout game, but with loose pockets, the advantage that comes with a fundamentally exceptional stroke would be greatly reduced, and that's not what would serve our sport's long-term interests.
 

logical

Loose Rack
Silver Member
Right on, Trent.

Every sport goes through this as the equipment and players improve. Golf and American football offer two good examples.

Golf
Championship golf courses set up for pro events tended to be about 6,800 yards forty years ago. With the advances in equipment and the increase in the number of good players, such courses today are about 7,200 years. The old setups were not long enough to properly challenge the world's best players.

American football
Kickoffs at either the beginning of the game or after a team scored were executed form the 40 yard line in the 1970's and these kickoffs were frequently returned as they didn't reach the end zone. As kickers became more skillful, however, the kickoff was moved back to the 35 yard line, avoiding a decline in returnable kickoffs.

In golf, American football, and also pool, it is recognized that the game must keep pace with the improvements in both equipment and players. Pool is still a runout game, but with loose pockets, the advantage that comes with a fundamentally exceptional stroke would be greatly reduced, and that's not what would serve our sport's long-term interests.
All true but I've played quite a few times on courses that host PGA events, even Majors. They are not set up the same the rest of the year for Joe Baggyshorts, even if he fancies himself a "scratch golfer".
 

garczar

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Right on, Trent.

Every sport goes through this as the equipment and players improve. Golf and American football offer two good examples.

Golf
Championship golf courses set up for pro events tended to be about 6,800 yards forty years ago. With the advances in equipment and the increase in the number of good players, such courses today are about 7,200 years. The old setups were not long enough to properly challenge the world's best players.

American football
Kickoffs at either the beginning of the game or after a team scored were executed form the 40 yard line in the 1970's and these kickoffs were frequently returned as they didn't reach the end zone. As kickers became more skillful, however, the kickoff was moved back to the 35 yard line, avoiding a decline in returnable kickoffs.

In golf, American football, and also pool, it is recognized that the game must keep pace with the improvements in both equipment and players. Pool is still a runout game, but with loose pockets, the advantage that comes with a fundamentally exceptional stroke would be greatly reduced, and that's not what would serve our sport's long-term interests.
As for golf, 7,200yds is not even considered long anymore. Senior tour plays on 7,200 sometimes. The modern equivalent is around 7,800(!!!) yds. Golf Digest&USGA did a study and said your avg. weekend player should not go over 6,200yds. Big difference. To me really tight pockets are like those 7,800yd courses, too tough for average Joes.
 
Last edited:

mchnhed

I Came, I Shot, I Choked
Silver Member
Tight pockets are a progression of the game.
Things change over time.

The Future?
 

Attachments

  • 7A61028E-5D7E-4B29-8EBE-FE5D96AF9035.jpg
    7A61028E-5D7E-4B29-8EBE-FE5D96AF9035.jpg
    189.5 KB · Views: 239
Last edited:

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
All true but I've played quite a few times on courses that host PGA events, even Majors. They are not set up the same the rest of the year for Joe Baggyshorts, even if he fancies himself a "scratch golfer".

Yes, excellent point.
 

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
As for golf, 7,200yds is not even considered long anymore. Senior tour plays on 7,200 sometimes. The modern equivalent is around 7,800(!!!) yds. Golf Digest&USGA did a study and said your avg. weekend player should not go over 6,200yds. Big difference. To me really tight pockets are like those 7,800yd courses, too tough for average Joes.

Yes, sounds like I understated how much tougher they've made golf. I love your comparison of the 7800 yard course to really tight pockets on a pool table --- right on the mark!
 

maha

from way back when
Silver Member
yes sjm the pro golfers play on entirely different courses and setups than the average and good fun golfer on the weekend does. and thats how it should be.

golf has different tees so each level of player can have fun. so does pool. and in pool it is the pocket size.

but the thread is about average pool players or players looking for a home table to have fun on and practice on. some would think they should have whatever the pros play on and make it tough. that's fine for them.

but the vast majority of people mostly outside of az ,want a fun table where you actually make lots of balls and keep shooting more than once at each turn.
 

garczar

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
yes sjm the pro golfers play on entirely different courses and setups than the average and good fun golfer on the weekend does. and thats how it should be.

golf has different tees so each level of player can have fun. so does pool. and in pool it is the pocket size.

but the thread is about average pool players or players looking for a home table to have fun on and practice on. some would think they should have whatever the pros play on and make it tough. that's fine for them.

but the vast majority of people mostly outside of az ,want a fun table where you actually make lots of balls and keep shooting more than once at each turn.
I've marshall'd at a couple golf courses. I often told people to move up and have fun. Many times they'd thank me. Pool's same way, pick the size that allows YOU to enjoy the game.
 

jimmyco

NRA4Life
Silver Member
I know you are in the business and have seen tons of original and restored tables and I'm not taking sides (lol, not that it would matter), but at an amateur level having quite a bit of experience with photography there are quite a few variables in play with that particular picture which could result in the differences, one of them simply being source and angle of the lighting in relation to the angle of the photographer. Just saying I'm not sure that they don't match is a foregone conclusion.

Having said that, if it's such a great table, and it looks amazing to me, I think I'd keep it! My old Anniversary doesn't look even a little bit as nice as that does, but the cushions are great, the slate is level and smooth and between the rails it is awesome (to me) - the rest are just some well earned battle scars from being 60+ years old, haha.

Viva la difference (or something like that).

Good post.
 

Paul Schofield

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Like golf that lengthens the course, pool does the same going from 7 to 8 to 9 and on to 10 foot tables. I don't see anything wrong with even a 12 foot table. Credit golf for not shrinking the target. Shrinking the target is dangerous to the definition and viability of every sport. A sport's popularity and success is very, very fragile.
 

deanoc

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
In the old days there would be many different size table and even different pockets on the same size

It was not uncommon for two players to play a set on table A
The loser might say,that's it for me,but if you want to play on table 4
we can jack the bet

It was always uncommon to find people who knew how to match up
And even those who got the 7 on a loose table and lose didn't realize
that if they went to the tight table the spot was greater

I used to play one of the best or highest players in town one pocket,
he could give me 8 to 6 and the break on the tight table and rob me.

He also knew if he played on the loose table that his ball running would
improve and he would be better off switching

Most of the experienced players and rail birds agreed so when I agreed to play on the

5inch pockets everyone bet accordingly

What they didn't realize was that the tight pockets were too tough for me,my
mechanics were not so good,but I also lost confidence and the loss of confidence
caused me to break down

The switch to the 5 inch pockets was a double advantage to me, now I not only shot
more balls in ,but the added confidence put me in stroke,that is to playing
my own top speed

Another added advantage was that it was difficult for him to get balls out of my hole.

these little things resulted in me making a nice size score,,even busting a couple of pool
detectives who thought they had the nuts when they didn't

You see fellas , I know what I like,I my pockets on my table, I even like the finish and looks,
more importantly my wife like the looks of it and is happy.

why anyone else cares if my finish is darker or lighter doesn't bother me. i would enjoy my
table if it were polka dot and lavender.

i never understood why some people criticize other peoples things. My next door neighbor
told my wife that our light colored walls was out of style.Now along comes a fella who looks at my pictures and says my table is ugly or doesn't reach his exalted standards of grace and beauty

My wife tells me not to worry,these people are jerks with no manners,she knows about hings like that.

If the color of my table legs offends any of the rest of you please feel free to complain

Jack Potter is talking about the heavy boot my doctor prescribed for my swollen leg,it is a medical thing,he thought it was a fashion statement. You see in Oak Cliff where we came from

people are not so sophisticated as they are up north
 

pt109

WO double hemlock
Silver Member
In the old days there would be many different size table and even different pockets on the same size

It was not uncommon for two players to play a set on table A
The loser might say,that's it for me,but if you want to play on table 4
we can jack the bet

It was always uncommon to find people who knew how to match up
And even those who got the 7 on a loose table and lose didn't realize
that if they went to the tight table the spot was greater

I used to play one of the best or highest players in town one pocket,
he could give me 8 to 6 and the break on the tight table and rob me.

He also knew if he played on the loose table that his ball running would
improve and he would be better off switching

Most of the experienced players and rail birds agreed so when I agreed to play on the

5inch pockets everyone bet accordingly

What they didn't realize was that the tight pockets were too tough for me,my
mechanics were not so good,but I also lost confidence and the loss of confidence
caused me to break down

The switch to the 5 inch pockets was a double advantage to me, now I not only shot
more balls in ,but the added confidence put me in stroke,that is to playing
my own top speed

Another added advantage was that it was difficult for him to get balls out of my hole.

these little things resulted in me making a nice size score,,even busting a couple of pool
detectives who thought they had the nuts when they didn't

You see fellas , I know what I like,I my pockets on my table, I even like the finish and looks,
more importantly my wife like the looks of it and is happy.

why anyone else cares if my finish is darker or lighter doesn't bother me. i would enjoy my
table if it were polka dot and lavender.

i never understood why some people criticize other peoples things. My next door neighbor
told my wife that our light colored walls was out of style.Now along comes a fella who looks at my pictures and says my table is ugly or doesn't reach his exalted standards of grace and beauty

My wife tells me not to worry,these people are jerks with no manners,she knows about hings like that.

If the color of my table legs offends any of the rest of you please feel free to complain

Jack Potter is talking about the heavy boot my doctor prescribed for my swollen leg,it is a medical thing,he thought it was a fashion statement. You see in Oak Cliff where we came from

people are not so sophisticated as they are up north

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AILZ6EeNeBE

Tell ‘em, Dean
 

logical

Loose Rack
Silver Member
In the old days there would be many different size table and even different pockets on the same size

It was not uncommon for two players to play a set on table A
The loser might say,that's it for me,but if you want to play on table 4
we can jack the bet

It was always uncommon to find people who knew how to match up
And even those who got the 7 on a loose table and lose didn't realize
that if they went to the tight table the spot was greater

I used to play one of the best or highest players in town one pocket,
he could give me 8 to 6 and the break on the tight table and rob me.

He also knew if he played on the loose table that his ball running would
improve and he would be better off switching

Most of the experienced players and rail birds agreed so when I agreed to play on the

5inch pockets everyone bet accordingly

What they didn't realize was that the tight pockets were too tough for me,my
mechanics were not so good,but I also lost confidence and the loss of confidence
caused me to break down

The switch to the 5 inch pockets was a double advantage to me, now I not only shot
more balls in ,but the added confidence put me in stroke,that is to playing
my own top speed

Another added advantage was that it was difficult for him to get balls out of my hole.

these little things resulted in me making a nice size score,,even busting a couple of pool
detectives who thought they had the nuts when they didn't

You see fellas , I know what I like,I my pockets on my table, I even like the finish and looks,
more importantly my wife like the looks of it and is happy.

why anyone else cares if my finish is darker or lighter doesn't bother me. i would enjoy my
table if it were polka dot and lavender.

i never understood why some people criticize other peoples things. My next door neighbor
told my wife that our light colored walls was out of style.Now along comes a fella who looks at my pictures and says my table is ugly or doesn't reach his exalted standards of grace and beauty

My wife tells me not to worry,these people are jerks with no manners,she knows about hings like that.

If the color of my table legs offends any of the rest of you please feel free to complain

Jack Potter is talking about the heavy boot my doctor prescribed for my swollen leg,it is a medical thing,he thought it was a fashion statement. You see in Oak Cliff where we came from

people are not so sophisticated as they are up north
OK...but why then are you trying to peddle it?

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk
 

JazzyJeff87

AzB Plutonium Member
Silver Member
I think the table looks pretty. The bright pockets are something new to me, it looks cool but I’m curious what it would be like to play on. Do they distract you at all or give you more of a target when you have a “corner of the eye” back cut?
 

pt109

WO double hemlock
Silver Member
I think the table looks pretty. The bright pockets are something new to me, it looks cool but I’m curious what it would be like to play on. Do they distract you at all or give you more of a target when you have a “corner of the eye” back cut?

I played on old Anniversaries that had those red pockets.... 40s or early 50s?
...snooker and pool.
...the tables always had wood rails rather than covered.
They were a Bakelite compound....made a great sharp sound when you drilled one center.
...and they didn’t grab your cue like the later cheaper pockets.
 

deanoc

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
jazzy jeff

the pockets I chose are red ,more red than the old ones

my table man offered to bring new black ones to me,and he might

my wife liked these even though i was undecided

Logical

i am not selling it on this thread or trying to draw attention to my offer elsewhere

i usually list everything i have for sale

this is well known

i like buying and selling and meeting people

the size of pockets on any table can be adjusted as far as i know
if i wanted to have smaller pockets all i need to do is make a call

i am not a good player as everyone knows,but for years i have been beating
people who tell me how much they love small pockets and how it can improve
your game

there is such a thing as pro cut pocket groupies
just because they call my pockets buckets doesn't mean they know how to play

i really like them now

it may all be in my head but they draw my attention and make
the shot look easier

i am not unhappy with them ,i like them
 

bstroud

Deceased
Dean,

You are right as is usually the case.

TrentfromToledo said it best: "I am not a good player."

He should have stuck with that instead of preaching about tight pockets.

How would he know?

Bill Stroud
 

logical

Loose Rack
Silver Member
Dean,



You are right as is usually the case.



TrentfromToledo said it best: "I am not a good player."



He should have stuck with that instead of preaching about tight pockets.



How would he know?



Bill Stroud
But Dean just said the very same thing about himself.

Sent from my SM-T830 using Tapatalk
 
Top