lower payout....
What a read...so let me add a players' perspective about a calcutta. I'm disappointed in the view that the lessor players can't win (from scott lee) so we should not have a calcutta. The idea of the tourney is winning against the other players no matter the skill level. Along with winning comes getting paid. The calcutta is a means to add to the payout. It stands to reason that more money means more, and better players. It also attracts bettors, railbirds, and spectators which is more customers in the pool room or bar having the tourney. This increases the room's revenue which can allow for it to "add" cash to the tourney. And more cash= more players!
It shouldn't detract lessor skilled players-it should energize them to be better.
The lessor skilled players should have the goal of getting better, while the higher skilled players would like to be rewarded for their efforts of being better. As a 'b' player, when I get to a tourney with a calcutta, I know I'm not the favorite to win because of the 'a' players in the room. But that becomes an incentive for me to play harder and beat those 'a' players to get a shot at not only the cash, but accomplishment of "being the best" so to speak.
A fair(?) alternative is to handicap the tourney. This way, the lessor skilled have a shot at winning also.I have been to many tourneys that are handicapped, and most of the time, provided the director knows the skill levels of the players involved it comes out fair. I'm not saying it's right or wrong, but I do know that NASCAR doesn't let the slow cars get a couple of laps in before jjimmy johnson and tony stewart hit the track!
Calcuttas by the way, are illegal EVERYWHERE. It's nothing more than gambling. So are football squares and college basketball brackets-but every march even the president fills out his picks for the NCAA tourney (not handicapped by the way). Calcuttas ADD money to the PLAYERS" pockets, and to the ROOM OWNERS pockets. If there was two tourneys going on simultaneously in two bars directly across the street from one another, and one had a calcutta and the other didn't....which tourney would have more players in it?