Any Lawyer's out there?

BazookaJoe

Destroyer of stickers
Silver Member
Who can tell me, in accordance with the link provided, how the Tennessee gambling law would affect the participation of two individuals in a set of 9 ball for financial enhancement?
 

SpiderWebComm

HelpImBeingOppressed
Silver Member
I'm not a lawyer, but it's para-mutual gambling - the equivalent of a home poker game. I don't think it's illegal. As long as the poolhall isn't cutting the action.
 
Last edited:

ScottW

Fo' shizzle!
Silver Member
BazookaJoe said:
Who can tell me, in accordance with the link provided, how the Tennessee gambling law would affect the participation of two individuals in a set of 9 ball for financial enhancement?

Um.... what link? :p
 

vagabond

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
It appears to me that the law is vague.I do not know whether they intentionally made the law to be Vague so that they can harass their political opponents or not.
If the local sheriff does not like you,he can arrest you and charge you for violating the gamblings laws of the state of Tennessee.
 

Yokel

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Tennessee State Code:

39-17-503.

(a) A person commits an offense who knowingly induces or aids another to engage in gambling, and:
(1) Intends to derive or derives an economic benefit other than personal winnings from the gambling; or
(2) Participates in the gambling and has, other than by virtue of skill or luck, a lesser risk of losing or greater chance of winning than one (1) or more of the other participants.
(b) The offense of gambling promotion is a Class B misdemeanor.


It's legal to gamble on pool as long as you aren't giving him a weighted ball to shoot with :) It is also out-lined here that it is illegal for a venue to make money off of your gambling... basically the only stipulations.
 

Yokel

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
vagabond said:
It appears to me that the law is vague.I do not know whether they intentionally made the law to be Vague so that they can harass their political opponents or not.
If the local sheriff does not like you,he can arrest you and charge you for violating the gamblings laws of the state of Tennessee.

They won't arrest you for gambling because, #1... it's legal... and #2... it would cost more money to arrest/process/detain/ and give you a trial than it would make the city on the citation cost. Any gambling violation is a midemeanor.
 

Tennesseejoe

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Yokel said:
Tennessee State Code:

39-17-503.

(a) A person commits an offense who knowingly induces or aids another to engage in gambling, and:
(1) Intends to derive or derives an economic benefit other than personal winnings from the gambling; or
(2) Participates in the gambling and has, other than by virtue of skill or luck, a lesser risk of losing or greater chance of winning than one (1) or more of the other participants.
(b) The offense of gambling promotion is a Class B misdemeanor.


It's legal to gamble on pool as long as you aren't giving him a weighted ball to shoot with :) It is also out-lined here that it is illegal for a venue to make money off of your gambling... basically the only stipulations.



Does this mean that a calcutta is illegal?
 

Yokel

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Tennesseejoe said:
Does this mean that a calcutta is illegal?

I must not be up on the lingo yet :( what is a calcutta?

I can tell you stakehorses that want a % of your winnings are illegal, venues that take a part off the purse are illegal, and any kind of machine that has less than a 50/50 chance of winning are illegal, unless the machine is state-owned, and a certain % of the money is used for purposes helping the people (usually schools).
 

vagabond

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Yokel said:
They won't arrest you for gambling because, #1... it's legal... and #2...


Even if one makes advances at the local sheriff`s mistress? It is good to know that I will not be arrested for playing for money.
I thought the law did not include pool in the exceptions.Pool could ,by some , can be seen as a game of chance.Game of chance will be condsidered gambling according to the Laws in Tennessee

Cheers to Tennessee.
 

Yokel

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
vagabond said:
Even if one makes advances at the local sheriff`s mistress? It is good to know that I will not be arrested for playing for money.
I thought the law did not include pool in the exceptions.Pool could ,by some , can be seen as a game of chance.Game of chance will be condsidered gambling according to the Laws in Tennessee

Cheers to Tennessee.

Yeah TN has it's perks :)

I wouldn't ever expect "game of chance" to hold up in court though, and I would literally laugh at trial at the prosecutor who brought it up. The only defense you need in that situation is to show the past 15 years of proffesional billiards. You wouldn't see the same 20 names winning every event if it were a game of chance, and I don't know of any chance game that is considered a professional sport.

There are professional games that involve more luck than others (poker, which is usually considered a "sport" in most places now, as well as a gambling game), but billiards would be easy to prove as a skill game.
 

hemicudas

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Tennesseejoe said:
Does this mean that a calcutta is illegal?

That is a good ??? for TN, Joe. In MS there was a case where one bar owner was charged with running a Calcutta and said it was gambling but when he went to court, without a lawyer, the judge threw it out immediately.
 

satman

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
When I had my poolrooms in Indiana, I checked on running tournaments and poker games. Pool is considered a game of skill. If the 2 players are the only ones betting, it's not illegal. If a stakehorse or any outside individual is passing money or betting on the game, it is gambling. I was told I could have a poker game, but the house may not take a cut or at that time charge for a seat. That law has changed I believe due to all the poker craze.
As far as the pool goes, I guess it's who you have mad at you. If the room owner is charging table time, maybe they could bust the game. If its a calcutta, those are illegal. You are betting on another persons skills.
That's my take on all that stupid crap with the laws. They're preparing to close any bar that runs a board so their patrons can gamble on Nascar, Baseball, football, or anything else,{including pull tabs} here in Muncie. But the horse track, 20 miles from us is getting a couple hundred slot machines, we have lotto and state run pull tabs and riverboats. But gambling is illegal. The bar owners don't even make anything off the boards. I hate politicians.
Sorry, I'm a little irritated. I have several friends in the bar business.
 

ScottW

Fo' shizzle!
Silver Member
hemicudas said:
That is a good ??? for TN, Joe. In MS there was a case where one bar owner was charged with running a Calcutta and said it was gambling but when he went to court, without a lawyer, the judge threw it out immediately.

Yah, but just because that happened once doesn't mean it's going to happen every time. Could be the judge that day was constipated or something. No telling.
 

rackmsuckr

Linda Carter - The QUEEN!
Silver Member
Harry Platis went to court and won, proving that pool is a skill, and not gambling. Thus, wagers placed on the outcome of the game/set/match are based on skill (however deluded :p ). However, side bettors (or any non-participant) are not allowed to bet.

Calcuttas are illegal, player auctions may not be. Semantics to be sure, but there may be a legal distinction.
 

Johnnyt

Burn all jump cues
Silver Member
satman said:
When I had my poolrooms in Indiana, I checked on running tournaments and poker games. Pool is considered a game of skill. If the 2 players are the only ones betting, it's not illegal. If a stakehorse or any outside individual is passing money or betting on the game, it is gambling. I was told I could have a poker game, but the house may not take a cut or at that time charge for a seat. That law has changed I believe due to all the poker craze.
As far as the pool goes, I guess it's who you have mad at you. If the room owner is charging table time, maybe they could bust the game. If its a calcutta, those are illegal. You are betting on another persons skills.
That's my take on all that stupid crap with the laws. They're preparing to close any bar that runs a board so their patrons can gamble on Nascar, Baseball, football, or anything else,{including pull tabs} here in Muncie. But the horse track, 20 miles from us is getting a couple hundred slot machines, we have lotto and state run pull tabs and riverboats. But gambling is illegal. The bar owners don't even make anything off the boards. I hate politicians.
Sorry, I'm a little irritated. I have several friends in the bar business.
And most politoians are lawyers sooooo....Johnnyt
 

JoeyA

Efren's Mini-Tourn BACKER
Silver Member
BazookaJoe said:
Who can tell me, in accordance with the link provided, how the Tennessee gambling law would affect the participation of two individuals in a set of 9 ball for financial enhancement?

PM Eric Yow, AZ's resident esquire who lives in Tennessee.
JoeyA
 

Yokel

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Cuaba said:
My lawyer tells me that free legal advice is worth what you pay for it.

Do what I would do in any situation except murder... represent yourself. You have to remember when dealing with PDs... they know the judge on a first-name basis and the outcome of your case is usually decided on alot more than just "the facts".
 
Top