Bad transaction report? When to give one?

George

Balance is everything
Silver Member
I recently purchased a cue from someone who posts on this forum. The cue was advertised as mint but when I received it there were problems. The cue was well packaged in bubble wrap and a hard cardboard shipping tube so I know the damage didn't occur during shipping.
During the process of buying the cue communication was great, several emails and PM's were exchanged and the transaction was completed. Now that I've paid for and received the cue and notified the seller of the problems I can't get a response to my emails.
I have PM'd him for several days and all I get is the runaround, you know, PM's back saying "I sent you 2 emails already" and "I'll check my mail sent bin and send them again" yet I've received nothing. He certainly didn't have any trouble reaching me when we were setting up the deal but now can't seem to send me an email so we can work out a solution to our problem. I should mention he's still posting here every day trying to buy and sell things.
My question is this........how long should I wait before I post a bad transaction report here on AZ? I feel I've been patient but I'm getting the runaround. I've been around a long time and I know the runaround when I see it. I'm hoping this post will motivate him to do the right thing before I expose his name to all here on the forum. I've attached a couple of pics of the problems with the cue........keep in mind this cue was advertised as *mint*.

Thanks for any and all suggestions,
George
 

Attachments

  • damaged wrap.jpg
    damaged wrap.jpg
    31.8 KB · Views: 586
Last edited:
another pic of same cue. 1st was of damaged wrap this is of a 3/4 inch dent in the forearm.
 

Attachments

  • damaged forearm.jpg
    damaged forearm.jpg
    25.3 KB · Views: 587
The Time to Post a Negative Report is when YOU FEEL THE SELLER is avoiding you, and refuses to reply to your PM's, and E-mails. Have they been on line since you tried to reach em?
 
PoolSleuth said:
The Time to Post a Negative Report is when YOU FEEL THE SELLER is avoiding you, and refuses to reply to your PM's, and E-mails. Have they been on line since you tried to reach em?

I emailed him on 4/29 about the problem and sent him PM's every day since. He has been posting here every day and has responded to my PM's briefly but that's it. The responses to my PM's were real quick saying he'd email me but 4 days have passed now and nothing. He hasn't responded to my last 2 PM's and I know he got them because I checked the box: "Request a read receipt for this message" and they were read. He was on today also.

George

edit: grammar correction
 
Last edited:
George

At this point, I would expose the seller and see what he has to say to the board. This would stop his sales until he replys and rectifies the situation. JMHO
Purdman:cool:
Sorry you have this problem. I know that most AZ sellers are straight up guys/gals.
 
Purdman said:
At this point, I would expose the seller and see what he has to say to the board. This would stop his sales until he replys and rectifies the situation. JMHO
Purdman:cool:
Sorry you have this problem. I know that most AZ sellers are straight up guys/gals.
I'm reluctant to give his name just yet, he could just be having a bad day(or 4)?

George
 
I would wait until you're certain he's seen this thread, then it's time to let us know who to avoid.
 
It is amazing what people will give as description and how they will lie about it. I was in the market for a car. I called the seller and talked to him and asked a lot of questions. The normal ones such as body damage, rust, shape of interior, was there smoking in the car etc. I told him that I had been looking and how people lie about the shape. He assured me there was none of that. The car was mint and that if I seen it I would buy it. He said that anyone seeing it would snap it up. The price of the car also reflected that of a premium condition. I told him that it was a 150 mile drive and it would be a few hours but it would be worth it if the car was that good.

Guess what. The car was in a garage. It had a smashed in hood and fender, a door missing, reeked of cigarettes, bird crap, a layer of dust, sitting on blocks with no wheels. Happy that it wasn't a EBay purchase.
 
I would make sure that the seller saw the thread before you post his name. It does sound like he is giving you the run around, but perhaps he will come through. If giving him a few extra days increases your chance for a refund or compensation, I would give it a chance.

I've bought several cues from AZ members and had one "sorta bad experience". The cue was not really as advertised and the seller eventually came through and I got most of the cost of the cue back (minus shipping, etc...). At first he said that he could not refund the cue since he no longer had the money due to paying off debts. Of course, this did not preclude him from buying other cues on ebay and trading....LOL.

At any rate, I'd send him another email saying that you intend to discuss the problem on this public forum unless the problem is addressed.

Regards,

Doug
 
Salamander said:
I've bought several cues from AZ members and had one "sorta bad experience". The cue was not really as advertised and the seller eventually came through and I got most of the cost of the cue back (minus shipping, etc...). At first he said that he could not refund the cue since he no longer had the money due to paying off debts. Of course, this did not preclude him from buying other cues on ebay and trading....LOL.

I am calling you a liar. If you were in front of me, I'd call it to your face. Want to bring out the whole story rather than your subtle (or should I say not so subtle) insults to this "unknown" person, which is me?

Eventually came through? Try within 24 hours. What exactly did I buy off of ebay, and how did I do any trading up?

You are anal beyond belief and expect to get brand new cues for used cue pricing. I disclosed everything as best as I knew and rectified the situation within 24 hours of you messaging the fact that you were displeased with the transaction. Want me to post the emails?

It amazing how much of a condescending ass you can be... Funny is that many have noticed too. I was very calm and professional in our transaction and went above and beyond to ensure that you were happy regardless and this is the thanks I get.....
 
1pRoscoe said:
I am calling you a liar. If you were in front of me, I'd call it to your face. Want to bring out the whole story rather than your subtle (or should I say not so subtle) insults to this "unknown" person, which is me?

Eventually came through? Try within 24 hours. What exactly did I buy off of ebay, and how did I do any trading up?

You are anal beyond belief and expect to get brand new cues for used cue pricing. I disclosed everything as best as I knew and rectified the situation within 24 hours of you messaging the fact that you were displeased with the transaction. Want me to post the emails?

It amazing how much of a condescending ass you can be... Funny is that many have noticed too. I was very calm and professional in our transaction and went above and beyond to ensure that you were happy regardless and this is the thanks I get.....

And the guy that ended up with the cue LOVES it AND loves the purchase price!! :D :cool:
 
1pRoscoe said:
I am calling you a liar. If you were in front of me, I'd call it to your face. Want to bring out the whole story rather than your subtle (or should I say not so subtle) insults to this "unknown" person, which is me?

Eventually came through? Try within 24 hours. What exactly did I buy off of ebay, and how did I do any trading up?

You are anal beyond belief and expect to get brand new cues for used cue pricing. I disclosed everything as best as I knew and rectified the situation within 24 hours of you messaging the fact that you were displeased with the transaction. Want me to post the emails?

It amazing how much of a condescending ass you can be... Funny is that many have noticed too. I was very calm and professional in our transaction and went above and beyond to ensure that you were happy regardless and this is the thanks I get.....

I spoke to you about how I felt this was handled. You were more professional than I would have been.

Ross, you'll always get the nod when it comes to buying and selling with me.

Take care buddy,
Koop
 
ScottR said:
And the guy that ended up with the cue LOVES it AND loves the purchase price!! :D :cool:

I think you sold it for the price as noted below, too, didn't you Scott?

I thought it was water under the bridge, but guess not. I thought I made everything happy for Doug, but guess not.

Just incase anyone wants to see....... Please show me how I eventually took care of you....

From: Douglas
To: Ross
Date: Mar 13, 2006 3:22 PM
Subject: Re: Jensen

Hi Ross,

I got the cue Sat. afternoon and finally had a chance to play with it Sunday evening. I have to tell you that I was a little dissapointed with the shafts. Both shafts have a fair wobble to them, one is greater than the other. While the cue is still playable, I really expected the shafts to be much straighter, as you seemed to indicate in your original post. The cue seemed to hit fine and the butt was straight. You can definately feel the rings with fingers, but I expected that, even though you said that you could not.

Overall, I'm not real satisfied with the deal, but I really don't feel that you intentionally mislead me. I would like to ask to return the cue and be refunded. If not, that's OK to, no big deal. Either way, I don't think I'll be hanging on to it.

Regards,

Doug

Note that he emails again as I didn't respond within 4 hrs

From: Douglas
To: Ross
Date: Mar 13, 2006 7:31 PM
Subject: Re: Jensen

Hey Ross,

Emailed you, but have not heard back? Did you get my last e-mail?

Thanks,

Doug

From: Ross
To: Douglas
Date: Mar 14, 2006 9:49 AM
Subject: Re: Jensen

Doug -

My apologies for the delay in responding, I was out of town this weekend through last night.

I'm sorry you find the transaction disappointing. I told you over the phone and posted that the cue was used and not 99-100% condition, hence the price. I disclosed all of the information to you as best as I could, as I would hope someone would for me. I did not run the shafts through a stringent inspection, as it always rolled true when put together. The cue hits phenomenal and I was very pleased with it, the few times that I played with it. You are correct, I did not intentionally mislead you, nor would I have for anyone that I have dealt with, as my history in transactions both on eBay and AzB will reflect.

I'm sorry that you are not completely satisfied with the deal, as I try to ensure that all people I deal with are completely happy in dealing with me. I would love to refund you the money and take the cue back, however financially I am not able to do so, as I had debts to resolve, hence the sale of this cue. I would be happy to assist you in reselling, and I'm sorry again that it did not work out to your expectations. The cue was used and advertised as so. I hope this doesn't dissuade you from dealing with me in the future.

Sincerely,

Ross


From: Douglas
To: Ross
Date: Mar 14, 2006 11:41 AM
Subject: Re: Jensen

Ross,

The cue was most certainly used and I knew that. It is probably on the order of 80% condition or worse when the shafts are taken into consideration. When I buy a cue, the MOST important aspect is whether the cue is straight and warp free, particularly the shafts since this is where all the play comes from. In the future, before you advertise that a cue is "perfectly straight together or apart", I suggest that you roll the shafts and the butt and actually check to make sure. There is no doubt on my part that I would not have purchased this cue at the price I did if I had any inkling that the shafts had the roll that they do. A fellow AZ member looked at it as well and thought they had a "significant amount of roll."

I myself operate on a system where I believe in total customer satisfaction, as such I have always offered to make things right with anyone who is disatisfied with my product. I have often found that Ebay and Azbilliards is a dumping ground for less than stellar cues. If I were to post this cue for sale again on AZbilliards and described it in more detail than you, do you think it would bring $550? I don't.

Honesty and integrity go along way.

Sincerely,

Doug

From: Ross
To: Douglas
Cc: Scott
Date: Mar 14, 2006 1:27 PM
Subject: Re: Jensen

Doug -

I understand that you are not happy with the transaction.

I operate with a strict customer satisfaction policy as well, however you cannot please everyone everytime, which is painfully obvious in this case. Do I think that the same cue would command $550 if you were to write the add? Yes. The same cue would cost more than double the price from Mike Johnson. I know that the cue is used, and the price reflected this as well.

If you believe that AzB and eBay are "dumping grounds for less than stellar cues", then why do you purchase used cues?

Yes, honesty and integrity go a long ways. Are you questioning mine? I'd like to hope not, as I have treated you with the utmost dignity and respect, and it appears that you have reciprocated this to me, up until the last line of the below email. If I were not, don't you think I would simply ignore you? Don't question my ethics, as they are quite high.

I have shard our entire transaction/email chain with a friend of mine whom is interested in taking this cue from you at the same price you paid. He has purchased several cues from me and can vouch for my integrity and honesty. It's evident that you cannot.........but alas, you cannot be a good guy in everyone's eyes.....

Please contact Scott , who is CC'd on this reply and he purchase this cue from you for the amount of $550.

You live, you learn...... Thanks for pointing out why I will not sell another cue online.

-Ross

From: Douglas
To: Ross
Cc: Scott
Date: Mar 14, 2006 2:13 PM
Subject: Re: Jensen

Ross,

I've bought and sold many cues both through Ebay and other on-line avenues. Some were better deals than others. Some disappointments, some great transactions. Overall, I do plan to curtail any further online sales.

You struck me as a very nice and honest guy over the phone. I do believe you when you say that you did not stringently inspect the cue. In retrospect, I wish you had inspected the cue a little more, and then perhaps we would not be in this situation.

As far as integrity, you are making moves in the right direction by at least offering the cue to Scott through me. With that in mind, how about we do this....

Scott, you are welcome to buy the cue from me at $550. I will even pay shipping, which puts me out about $25. When you receive the cue, if you are dissatisfied in any way, I'm sure that Ross, being a friend of yours, will make it right as he sounds as if he is vouching for the condition of the cue.

You can contact me via email, or, if you like, call me at 303-xxxxxx. Payment can be made in the same fashion that I paid for the cue, either with postal money order or with Cashiers check. I'll take Paypal, if you pay the fees. My address is:



Cue will be shipped with tracking number and insured.

Let me know.

Thanks,

Doug
 
Last edited:
Koop said:
I spoke to you about how I felt this was handled. You were more professional than I would have been.

Ross, you'll always get the nod when it comes to buying and selling with me.

Take care buddy,
Koop

Thanks, Koop, you're a true friend.
 
George said:
I emailed him on 4/29 about the problem and sent him PM's every day since. He has been posting here every day and has responded to my PM's briefly but that's it. The responses to my PM's were real quick saying he'd email me but 4 days have passed now and nothing. He hasn't responded to my last 2 PM's and I know he got them because I checked the box: "Request a read receipt for this message" and they were read. He was on today also.

George

edit: grammar correction

Think you have been SCREWED, as Apparently the Seller is not Responding to U... Think the time has come to post the Scoundrels HANDLE....:mad:
 
Well Roscoe,

Now that you brought it up, yes I think you were deceptive in your advertising the cue. This Jensen has changed hands more than I change my underwear in a month. You only managed to "make things right" by getting Scott to buy the cue. Scott in turn sold it within a week of receiving it (at least he mentioned that the shafts had a roll to them). The new buyer might be happy with the cue....good for him. I was not happy, and you were too cheap to take it back. As for Koop, he's jumping in because he unloaded it off on you Roscoe.

You certainly did not fully "disclose" the condition of the cue to me. You claimed everything was straight, when it was far from it. You are a disceptive and dishonest seller as far as I am concerned.

As far as my being anal, well, you managed to keep and fish out the old emails that we sent back and forth. I'd suggest that you go get a life.

This thread is closed for me. Maybe you should let the thread belong to George?




1pRoscoe said:
I am calling you a liar. If you were in front of me, I'd call it to your face. Want to bring out the whole story rather than your subtle (or should I say not so subtle) insults to this "unknown" person, which is me?

Eventually came through? Try within 24 hours. What exactly did I buy off of ebay, and how did I do any trading up?

You are anal beyond belief and expect to get brand new cues for used cue pricing. I disclosed everything as best as I knew and rectified the situation within 24 hours of you messaging the fact that you were displeased with the transaction. Want me to post the emails?

It amazing how much of a condescending ass you can be... Funny is that many have noticed too. I was very calm and professional in our transaction and went above and beyond to ensure that you were happy regardless and this is the thanks I get.....
 
PoolSleuth said:
Think you have been SCREWED, as Apparently the Seller is not Responding to U... Think the time has come to post the Scoundrels HANDLE....:mad:

I actually received an email from him around 11:30am eastern. He didn't offer up any solution so I emailed him back with what I think is a fair resolution. I offered 2 choices: 1)....I'll live with the dent in the forearm but I want HIM to pay for a new wrap or 2)....refund me the money and I'll ship the cue back. I'm awaiting his response. I'll keep you all posted.

George
 
Salamander said:
Well Roscoe,

Now that you brought it up, yes I think you were deceptive in your advertising the cue. This Jensen has changed hands more than I change my underwear in a month. You only managed to "make things right" by getting Scott to buy the cue. Scott in turn sold it within a week of receiving it (at least he mentioned that the shafts had a roll to them). The new buyer might be happy with the cue....good for him. I was not happy, and you were too cheap to take it back. As for Koop, he's jumping in because he unloaded it off on you Roscoe.

You certainly did not fully "disclose" the condition of the cue to me. You claimed everything was straight, when it was far from it. You are a disceptive and dishonest seller as far as I am concerned.

As far as my being anal, well, you managed to keep and fish out the old emails that we sent back and forth. I'd suggest that you go get a life.

This thread is closed for me. Maybe you should let the thread belong to George?


I really have nothing else to say, as the emails that I posted tell the whole story. Funny how you just made a complete 180 from our last correspondance.....

I was too cheap? **** you, I would've taken it back had I had the cash at the time.

You were taken care of and you know it. You just feel the need to whine, *****, and complain about something, and your life is not fulfilled enough to get your joy elsewhere...

I sure hope we don't ever run into each other later on.....
 
1pRoscoe said:
I sure hope we don't ever run into each other later on.....

Or what...are you going to resort to violence? Sounds like a threat to me. Boy are you a nasty little guy.
 
Salamander said:
Well Roscoe,

Now that you brought it up, yes I think you were deceptive in your advertising the cue. This Jensen has changed hands more than I change my underwear in a month. You only managed to "make things right" by getting Scott to buy the cue. Scott in turn sold it within a week of receiving it (at least he mentioned that the shafts had a roll to them). The new buyer might be happy with the cue....good for him. I was not happy, and you were too cheap to take it back. As for Koop, he's jumping in because he unloaded it off on you Roscoe.
You certainly did not fully "disclose" the condition of the cue to me. You claimed everything was straight, when it was far from it. You are a disceptive and dishonest seller as far as I am concerned.

As far as my being anal, well, you managed to keep and fish out the old emails that we sent back and forth. I'd suggest that you go get a life.

This thread is closed for me. Maybe you should let the thread belong to George?

I said nothing about you, only the fact that I regard Ross as honest and forthright.
What an a-hole thing to say. I dumped the cue on Ross?

My advice to you is to stop buying used cues in hopes of getting a new cue at a used cue price. And to think I thought you were a decent guy when we spoke on the phone. Talk about deception :rolleyes:

I'm done here.
Ross, as always, keep in touch, but I have no time for degenerate a-holes like Doug who are going to call into question my motives.
 
Back
Top