Mind if I ask which model of Meucci? If it’s older, the reason the Tweetens works is because of the massive diameter of the exposed wood tenon. When the tip comes off, you end up finding a blue ring around the outside of the ferrule where the bond broke down between the cement and the plastic ferrule. But the leather remains stuck to the wood tenon.
Lou, we can argue this all day long. I have done cue repairs for nearly 20 years. Go ask any quality repair guy as to how good Tweetens tip cement is for tips. I don’t even have it anymore. Loctite Prism or Gorilla Super Glue is all I use now for tips. Been that way for a long time now.
It would be an older Meucci that still has a tip I installed over 25 years ago firmly attached.
I recognized that you have done cue repairs for almost 20 years. I've been using Tweeten's for over 40.
In any case, this thread is not about what glue a cue mechanic should use -- it's about what a do-it-yourselfer should use. Presumably the guy has no lathe and is going to make a mess his first few times out and for that I still believe he's best off using Tweeten's, which he can effectively clean up afterwards.
BTW, this morning I recalled that I had some Elmer's rubber cement in the house and I looked at a dab of rubber cement next to a dab of Tweeten's. They are totally different in viscosity, color, and smell and I seriously doubt you could use the rubber cement for a tip install.
Also this morning, I sent an email to Tweeten up in Chicago and mentioned your claims about their product's similarity to a rubber cement formulation, its adhesion properties, and viable applications vis a vis various ferrule materials. I'll let you know when/if they respond.
Lou Figueroa