My main player is a Black Titlist, I fell in love with the way it plays! Is it because it's made from a Titlist blank? No, not in my opinion. It's because the butt was done by a top notch builder, the shaft and taper is (in my opinion) the best available. Kind of funny, but when I had the cue built I was given the option of having one of the shafts made from Timeless Timber Sunken Maple (pretty sure that the correct name) I declined and got two of his regular shafts. Both of those shafts are great, but in the back of my head I thought "wonder is the sunken Maple would play even better?". I ended up having another shaft built not to long ago.
I asked, why is everyone so big on Titlist conversions before I had mine built. And, really its more about the history and the quality at the time. Building a full splice is not the easiest thing to do, obviously it can be done well, but it is very labor intensive. Hell, even now most cuemakers don't want to mess with building a FS. At the time the Blanks were very plentiful and reasonably good quality, that's why everyone used them!
Personally, I like old school looks and it doesn't get any better than Titlist veneers, straight grain maple and nice butt wood!
Not to mention, he doesn't build many Titlist. Who would pass up having having one built?
Do they play better than any other FS? No.
Is there something special about them? No.
Do they hold a special place in cue history? Absolutely!
I have a few in my collection, some are great playing and some I don't like at all. It's really about personal preference.