I've replaced several tips with Medium's from Tiger: Everest and Sniper. Both times the customer response where positive. Spin is not something that dramatically changes from a tip change generally. Sound and feedback (feel) does change subjectively. I replaced my kamui soft on my viking siege with elk master as an experiment as I felt confident I'd be able to adjust. Sounded and felt different for sure, but my game didn't change including spinning for position play. I won't be sticking with the elk master though as the durability isn't good. Also, when gluing them the superglue bonds almost immediately with no working time, so aligning the tip is critical to get it right the first time. Made that mistake on my first install, on my son's cue and I just left it messed up cause he only has one speed anyway, SMASH! The Tiger tips have a bottom colored layer that gives you 10-30 seconds of fiddling to get everything lined up right. I shape, and burnish the elk 3x as often the amount as the Everest. Price wise can't beat'em but layered tips are just miles ahead for consistency and durability.