I empathize and sympathize with your opinion about others insulting members of the forum. However, the site is dependent upon traffic and that includes posters. The more the better. Forcing people to pay for a membership just so that they can post isn't going to solve the problem of insults. Having a "membership" might even give the insulters a confidence that they have the right to insult.
Anyway, not a bad idea, just one that probably can't work on this site.
Just my $.02.
I agree.
Imho the only way to deal with insults etc is through moderation. This is always a difficult balancing act but it is easy to see when it is working and when it is not: if the moderation is good, a forum will thrive. If the moderators have got the balance wrong, a forum will decline and wither. In my view, the moderators of this forum do an excellent job, as evidenced by the continued popularity of the forum.
No-one should be reluctant to post for fear of getting into a flame war. Just keep the following point in mind:
This is a public forum, not a vehicle for private conversations or arguments. So before posting anything, think whether your intended post is likely to be of interest
to the general readership (members and guests). If it is, then go ahead and post. But if the real reason for your response is only to justify yourself, or to chastise someone for not reading an earlier post more carefully etc etc then take a deep breath and press the delete button. Such posts are hardly ever of any interest to the general viewer and can rapidly lead to a thread's premature demise.
If a member follows this advice, I dont see why he should ever get into a flame war and therefore has nothing to fear. :smile:
Just a thought. (And thanks to the OP for starting this thread - much appreciated :thumbup