I thought the OP wanted to keep it under a $100, and threw out the $50 Lucky sneaky pete as an example? After replacing the tip, he would have invested closer to $70-$80.
FWIW, I picked up a used MG logo Sledgehammer for about $125. Brand new Sledgehammers go for $275 to $500. So, getting a used BK (BK1 or BK2) for a fraction of a new one isn't unrealistic. Especially if the seller only cares about having the latest and greatest.
When I don't feel like putting the break cue together, I'll break with my playing cue. The only issue is dealing with the tip mushrooming afterwards. So, I'll dial down the power a little and spend more effort aiming at the 1-ball. I've notice I've been getting a ball in on the break just as often, but the cue ball doesn't scratch.
It's true that I'm trying to keep the total cost under $100. As I said in another post, I've been looking for modestly
priced used break cues, but haven't been able to find any. Thus I'm looking at other options. The J&J Spark
break cue looks interesting because of the additional weight bolts that come with it. Any others with experience
with the Spark break cue?
Thanks again for all the responses, I'm following them closely.