I just got my Andy Gilbert last Thursday and I'm loving it. I had a Judd before and it's a very nice cue. But, I just can't get used to the balance. It's a little butt heavy for my taste. I know it's a matter of opinion but for me my Gilbert plays much better than my Judd. Also, I love the shaft not being pro tapered. I also have a Tim Scruggs, Bob Frey, and Richard Black. I would put my Gilbert on the top among the other cuemakers that I mentioned.