Appriciate the thoughts Misha. Good points.
The reason I was making a list is so that when I do call a cuemaker and he asks me what I'm looking for in a cue, I could tell him to the best of my ability. A wish list if you will. I certainly wouldn't dream of telling him how to build a cue. That's his job, not mine and that's what he gets paid the big bucks for. Knowlegde and expertise. On the other hand if I say I want a particular shaft taper or a particular type of wood used on the forearm (cocobola) and another (birdseye) on the wrapless handle I expect him to build it that way unless he tells me it's a bad idea and proceeds to explain why. I also would take any suggestions by him seriously. If he thinks he can improve upon what I think I want then I expect that from him as a craftsman and artist also. I'm not looking at some out of this world cue. Actually probably closer to the opposite and pretty much on the simple side compared to most customs I've looked at.
I'v got it basically as a cocobola forearm (no points or inlays), wrapless birdseye handle section with the buttsleeve cocobola also. I 'd also like to have the cuemaker use his artistic side and use some kind of cocobola inlays in the wrapless handle section. Ring work is his choice and probably most everything else except for my choice of shaft taper and tip. So tomorrow I get to find out (making my first calls) if I'm being unrealistic and I may be in for an eye opening experience. Looking foward to it either way.
Thanks again.
Keep the list, you'll learn from it, I been around cues and cue makers in many shops fopr about 20 years. I cant change a tip. I'm helpless-but I do know what I like in a cue. I have never stopped learning about cues. I know what pin,tip,ferrel,taper,woods(big list)i like/dislike, joint material, radial or flat face. points, etc etc etc.
Some stuff I learned in my first year, some things i'm learning now. I have went back to something I didnt like just to make sure I didnt like it, and i have sometimes found out I was wrong or I was right. Point is its not a knowlege contest, its finding what you like or dislike and the search for the ultimate cue-that search is fun, and along the way you learn to play, and as your game changes so does your cue preferance. like kids they dont play with the same toys from 2 yrs old to 12 years old, their toys change as do our cues. JA just got a new cue-he called me about it yesterday so excited about it he couldnt stop stuttering. And how many cues has he had, and how does he play. Truth be told he knows how to use a cue better than we do, yet his technical knowlege is limited.
So keep your list, have fun, play good, learn and then you'll be a well rounded pool player/cue guy.