Gilbert or Carmeli

[orbit516]

Hello All! I am having a very tough time deciding between these two cues. Both are gorgeous and both cuemakers seem to be well liked on this forum. I can have this version Carmeli with colored veneers for $1000

http://jjcue.com/images/AC10-2.jpg

or
I can get this 2011 Andy Gilbert for $1200

http://www.recollectioncues.com/gilbert6ptbesilver.html

These cues are too nice and I cannot seem to decide. Based on experience can anyone tell me how a carmeli plays and how a gilbert plays? What are the differences of feedback and feel to these cues? Also resale? Any help would be appreciated Thanks in advance!

 

[gunzby]

Wow I thought it would be easy till I clicked the links. I think a coin flip might be in order. I will say that I like the wrap on the Gilbert more. Then again I like the veneer colors on the Carmeli more.

 

[orbit516]

Tough decision right! To make things harder the carmeli cue is also offered in a cocobolo with green and orange veneers. Too tough..

 

[gunzby]

Tough decision right! To make things harder the carmeli cue is also offered in a cocobolo with green and orange veneers. Too tough..

In that case I would go with the Carmeli. I have a soft spot for cocobolo

 

[maidenfreak]

Owned many. Carmeli all the way.

 

[orbit516]

Decided to go with this one..Aint she a beauty?

 

[Ratta]

Really a nice wood-combo- for me also a real beauty
Whish you always a smooth stroke with it

lg from overseas,

ingo

 

[KCRack'em]

love at first sight

I'm really digging the cue you chose. Hope she treats you right!
Congrats!
Karl

 

[gunzby]

Very nice choice. Congrats

 

[metallicane]

I own 2 Carmeli's. Love them.