Are the characteristics and hit of the Olney similar to the Josey? That is, forward-balanced, stiff-hitting with a wood-to-wood joint. If not, what cue is more similar to a Josey?
Why not just buy another Josey? Unless you're looking for something a bit different, of course.
One day at my favorite hall, another player with a Josey & I switched cues. Even though they were made several years apart, we were both amazed how alike they were...one hit just like the other.
You found out what cue you like so stick with it. You can get one of his hustler cues for $250ish new. There is one in the for sale section that is $230 that looks real good.