Bayshore Billiards is about a half hour South East, Raxx in Hempstead is a about a half hour West and Steinway is about an hour West. These are the three closest/best that I can think of. Felt is nearby, but I haven't been there yet. Mr. Cue in Lindenhurst may be open and is a little closer. They moved and are waiting on some licenses. When are you coming to NY?
Where did Mr Cue move to?