universal rating system

Egg McDogit

street player
Silver Member
This is based on win % against 9 ball ghost in a race to 9 on an average difficulty 9' table. what do you think?

85%+ Shortstop+
75% A+
66% A
50% A-
33% B+
15% B
5% B-
1% C+
 
Egg McDogit said:
This is based on win % against 9 ball ghost in a race to 9 on an average difficulty 9' table. what do you think?

85%+ Shortstop+
75% A+
66% A
50% A-
33% B+
15% B
5% B-
1% C+

Does "against 9 ball ghost" mean ball in hand after the break? Is scratching on the break loss of game? If you make the 9 on the break, is that a win or does it spot? What about early combos on the 9?

If the answer is ball in hand after break, scratching on break is a loss, 9 spots if it goes in on the snap, and early 9 is a win, then I think these percentages look pretty good.

However, I don't think the ghost is a very good measure of a player's overall 9-ball ability. So many games are decided on safeties and responses to safeties (attempted kick-ins or kick-safes), and all the ghost measures is run-outs. I also think the 9-ball ghost is a poor indicator of ability in other games; especially 14.1 and 1pocket, but also 8-ball, utilize very different offensive skill-sets.

-Andrew
 
Back
Top