There is a sticky at the top of the Wanted/For Sale section of this forum with the rules for posting in this section. One of those rules is that comments on pricing are not to be made in someone else's FS thread....no matter the reason...period. Your comments were such that you likely killed the OP's chances at making a sale.
Okay...on to the Milk Duds themselves. The original Milk Duds were a little something the Filipinos came up with. Here in the states, I believe it was Mike Johnson of Jensen Cues who first began offering them. Mueller's did not begin offering the Dudley tips until a little better than a year ago now.
I have tried the Dudleys, and another AZ member's version, Milk Dudz...which I personally found to be better, IMHO, than the Dudleys.
But, I prefer the ones made by Mike Johnson which are the Milk Duds. They are more consistent from tip to tip, and I have had zero problems with them. I would suspect that the reason for this is that Mike is taking his time to go through and use only the best of the Elkmasters in each box. His tips go on clean and easy, and are pre-domed for ease of shaping. They absolutely do not mushroom or glaze over. Hold chalk extremely well, and do not flatten out ( I break with my player) like some of the others do. The fact that they help me to move the CB around with ease, with no miscues, is definitely a bonus!
Some people liken the feel and hardness of the Milk Duds as to that of a well broken-in old Le Pro.
Lisa