I have a similar story. I was at the US Open in the early 90s and watched Earl warm up. He repeatedly shot the shot you described, except that he drew the cue ball back to the end rail (and I don't remember him missing any of the shots).It's close between:
Also, I have an Earl story. One time I was watching a young Earl (21-22) practice before a match. For some unknown reason, he started shooting out of a corner jaw to a ball in the middle of the table exactly straight into the far corner. He was jacking up way more than he needed to and hitting it as hard as a break shot. I don't know why he was doing that. He probably shot that shot 20 times and probably made 17 or 18. It was scary weird to watch someone shoot that hard and that straight while jacked up out of the corner and be that accurate.
- Filler
- Shaw
- Earl
- Worst (from the stories I've read)
- Trump
- Dennis Orcollo
So my choice would be Earl in his prime. Incidentally, I heard Jim Wych in an interview say that he would choose Earl to shoot the shot if his life was on the line.