Search results

  1. GideonF

    Playing in BCA league that doesn't use Fargo.

    Go to Fargorate.com and search for your name.
  2. GideonF

    Playing in BCA league that doesn't use Fargo.

    Perhaps a dumb question but have you searched yourself on Fargo?
  3. GideonF

    Best site for team shirts?

    Pics or it didn’t happen.
  4. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    The BCA Pool League (CSI) rules have a very useful “applied rulings” that does this - probably from issues that have arisen at their events or questions from leagues. I often look at it when weird issues arise (eg whether a ball is “frozen” to a rail when it is only touching fibers from the rail).
  5. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    Thanks for this. So in the clip I shared what should happen? The 2b goes down obviously, but what do we do with the balls disturbed by the 2? Leave them as they lie or try to replace them? Oddly as written a ball that falls out the bottom of a broken pocket might not be pocketed (as it never...
  6. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    I would be curious what Bob Jewett or Dr Dave think is the correct ruling on the ball that goes in one pocket and out the other. The WPA rule says a ball is pocketed “when it enters the ball return system”, which to me means it is indeed pocketed, as the ball clearly entered the ball return...
  7. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    A ball should not pop out of another pocket from the ball return no matter how hard you hit it. The fact that Diamond sent a technician out to fix it speaks volumes. Also, unless someone is slamming the ball in for no reason, they probably aren’t “hitting too hard” - they are hitting hard...
  8. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    Apparently in this case Diamond saw the video and sent a technician out to fix the table. I don’t think a properly functioning ball return does this.
  9. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    Here is an even crazier example, where the ball goes into the pocket and comes out a different pocket. Reading the WPA rules it says that a ball is pocketed “when it enters the ball return system” which to me means the 2b is pocketed. But that seems very odd in this case - because the 2 is...
  10. GideonF

    Rules Question - Why

    So this just came up on my Facebook feed. https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1A8J7UDZzi/?mibextid=wwXIfr I know the ruling is that the ball that doesn’t stay down isn’t considered pocketed. My question is why? I mean if the pocket was full and he shot it anyway then I guess I can see that the...
  11. GideonF

    Controversial Non-Call of WRONG-BALL-HIT-FIRST FOUL - Hanoi Open - Capito vs. Lechner Quarter Final

    The ref said it was indeed a good hit on the yellow. The point of my post was to point out that because he thought he MIGHT have fouled he wanted the ref to check.
  12. GideonF

    Controversial Non-Call of WRONG-BALL-HIT-FIRST FOUL - Hanoi Open - Capito vs. Lechner Quarter Final

    Here is a video of the incident I mentioned where a player (Shaun Murphy) asked the ref to watch a replay of the shot to make sure he hit the right ball. https://www.facebook.com/share/r/1FBGHRHatB/?mibextid=wwXIfr
  13. GideonF

    Sigel vs. Varner, US Open 9-Ball semifinals, 1990

    Well it was rack for your opponent, so unless they were agreeing to tilt for each other…
  14. GideonF

    Sigel vs. Varner, US Open 9-Ball semifinals, 1990

    This is the first match I can recall watching that has the earlier rule about scratching on the break in 9b. BIH behind the headstring, lowest ball spots if it’s behind the headstring (I’m assuming that’s what happened). Also interesting that the ball made on the break spots as well - I wouldn’t...
  15. GideonF

    Break tips.. whats good?

    Has anyone here tried the new Cuetec jump/break tip they just released? Reviews?
  16. GideonF

    When are MISCUE and SCOOP Shots Fouls?

    I generally agree with Poolplaya9. In addition to his points, I would note the following: 1 The video you linked on “all miscues are fouls” includes scoop shots as being multiple hits or secondary hits, when your more recent video says they are not always so. This raises two points: (a) those...
  17. GideonF

    Calcutta Cease & Desist Order in Washington State

    I’ve only ever seen it done as cash in person at the venue.
  18. GideonF

    Break tips.. whats good?

    Yes. They told me they expected them to be out “this summer”, which has obviously come and gone. So I don’t know when but there should be one coming out.
  19. GideonF

    10-ball rules: Miscue on the break, rack not touched?

    Is that just for 10b, or 9b too? Also, where is this - just curious as I’ve never seen this practice in tournament play.
  20. GideonF

    10-ball rules: Miscue on the break, rack not touched?

    I have seen that done once. I think in that circumstance people would in fact treat it as other than a normal break (no push etc)
Back
Top