Yes, but with enough practice, nothing is mechanical. Take this video for example. You don't have to watch the whole thing, but a few things are very clear.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vIqY_8XeyfE
He has pretty much the same rhythm and stroke mechanics on every shot. A few very short and fast warm up strokes. A slight pause at the CB. Smooth backswing with a slight pause lasting anywhere from 1 to 2 seconds.
The reason I bring up this video is that no doubt he has practiced this over and over again, so now even though it appears mechanical, it's not. It's simply a part of his subconscious and he doesn't think about how many warm up strokes, or how long he pauses. It just happens.
Some pros pause, and some don't. Some drop their elbow, and some don't. There are numerous other differences. The one thing they all have in common is a consistent rhythm that is suited to their style of play.
It's my belief that the best (maybe not the only) way to achieve this level of consistency is to be consciously aware of what you're doing during practice sessions and to focus on the positives.
A great way to find consistency is to record yourself playing multiple racks of 15 balls in any order. Watch it back, and focus not just on the racks you do well on, but the individual shots as well. Through proper observation a player can easily pick up on a solid tempo. Then they might try to practice a wide variety of shots and positional play while focusing diligently on maintaining that consistency. Over a period of time it will no longer require such conscious effort.
I'm sure I could say more, but I feel like I've rambled enough.
I watched the first 4 shots & 1, 2, & 3 were all different. Yes he has a long pause on some shots like the first & fourth but the 2nd. & 3rd. were different. That is a bit of what I mean. Even he is allowing the pause to vary. There are varying amounts of being mechanical. I would say that he is mechanical compared to Efrin, Busty, Earl, etc. That does not mean that one can not shoot well or be successful. It's just a different approach & when one is using contrived mechanics it usually takes much practice as you have eluded to get those engrained but since they are not of a natural nature they must also be maintained or much 'rust' can appear on the mechanical mechanism.
As always, it is to each his own. Once one has made their own determination they have to own it as best that they can.
Shoot Well & Best Wishes & Regards,
Rick
Last edited: