10 ball vs 9 ball vs set length

Tin Man

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Is 10 ball really an improvement if it means shorter sets?

We all know why pool has steered towards 10 ball for many tournaments and matching up. Obviously in an even length set it is a more difficult game and rewards a more rounded skill set.

The problem is that tournament matches still have a limited time. Whereas we used to play 9 ball race to 11, now it seems to be 10 ball race to 7. With the set length reduced that much, is it really a better test of skill in a tournament format?
 
A 10-ball race takes slightly longer than the same race in 9-ball...randyg
 
Even if the set is reduced I think it is an improvement. The break needs to be hit hard and as of yet the soft break has not been perfected. 10 ball also promotes much more play per rack. 9 ball for top level players is just too much of a breaking contest no matter how long the set is, see SVB vs Scott Fost. In 10 ball you need a much larger skill set to play it well. IMO
 
10-ball is the better game by far. Add to that, 10-ball on break don't count, call shot, no patern racking, and no jump-cues. 10-ball is a good game for any size table IMO. F TV, they had their chance. Lets go back to real pool with race to 9 and longer races for semi and finals. Just the time you save from all the racking problems in 9-ball would make up for longer races in 10-ball. Johnnyt
 
clarity

GUYS! I understand that 10 ball is a better game. This is not a debate about which game involves more skill.

My point is, however, that longer sets also involve more skill. Personally I would rather race to 13 playing 6 ball then play one game of sudden death 10 ball. I just know that travelling across the country to play a race to 7 is brutal, even playing 10 ball. I would rather play 9 ball race to 9 then 10 ball race to 7.

Thanks to those that answered the question posed.

Who knows how to set up a poll? Race to 7 10 ball or race to 9 9 ball? Which is better?

PS Assuming big tables, break from the box. SVB and SF played on a small track.

OK, let's roll!
 
Back
Top