Yes, this is a new rule.
First, let me put it into its proper perspective.
It is rare, very rare, that a foul occurs when shooting the 9-ball, when the 9-ball is the only object ball left on the table.
I think it has only happened once, that I can recall, in the last three years of the US Open.
That incident was captured on tape. Shannon Daulton pocketed the 9-ball and then laid his cue on the table.
The cue ball was still in motion and just barely made contact with Shannon's cue stick.
Shannon's opponent, Karl Boyes, called a foul.
I was the referee and after reviewing the video, I ruled in Boyes' favor.
This new spot shot rule was put into place mainly for the fans.
Why should the game end unceremoniously on a foul?
Spot shots occur with regularity in 14.1, 8-Ball, one-pocket, banks, etc.
Every pool fan can relate to shooting a spot shot.
A pro should have no trouble making a spot shot.
It adds an element of excitement that is sometimes lacking in 9-ball.
Rules in spectator sports are constantly evolving to add excitement and drama: designated hitters, 3-point shots, sudden death, tie-breakers, etc.
I think we, as pool fans (and I count myself as one), should be willing to try to improve the game in an effort to attract more fans, sponsors, and recognition.
This spot shot rule, I think, is a small step in that direction.
I expected that there would be some pool fans who wouldn't like this rule.
But, I urge you to keep an open mind and let's see how it plays out.
Karl Kantrowitz, Tournament Director
2017 U.S. Open 9-Ball Championship
