I have both Big Beulah's. I like both of them. The BB2 is much nicer with the wood shaft. I can break about the same with either. I had to shorten my bridge a little with the BB2 because of the longer taper, but I've improved my 9-ball breaking with it. It does take some time to get used to the smaller tip size compared to the BB1. The wrap on the BB2 is a better pattern and more tacky like than the BB1. Overall, I think the BB2 was a better choice for me.
I was one of the fortunate ones to win the cue on face book before it hit the market. I really like it, best break cue I've used so far and it has a very solid hit compared to the other cues I've tried with the phenolic ferrule/tip featured on similar break cues.
I personally wasn't a big fan of the original painted wood shaft either. I don't like the thinner 12.75mm shaft that comes standard on the new Big Beulah II but it does come with a free upgrade option which is 13.75mm (which is what I break with) and I like it much better and I find it breaks better but It's all personal preference. It sounds like you will like the thicker taper. Man, It breaks a ton and I haven't found another break cue that hits as hard. Good luck with whatever you end up.
Good point Wes, although the upgrade to 13.75 isn't free it costs a few bucks.
the main thing that bothered me with the original bb is the shaft stuck to my hand like a titanium stick from wal-mart. everything else felt great to me. i play with a LH cue and love the laminated shaft on it and the feel of the cue. does the bb2 have that sticky feel or is it more like the playing cue feel