The very best break cue I ever had was a Joss player that I used as a break cue for about 15 years...never changed the tip, just let it glaze over and get VERY hard with use. That thing broke like a beast, with awesome control. I ended up giving it to my son as a player (with a new shaft) and went with a $200 J/B. It works okay, but nothing like an old player with a hard tip. If you've got an old playing cue lying around, put a hard tip on it and keep it relatively flat (nickel bevel or less). Break with it for just a few hours, I'll bet you'll be impressed.