Manley Shot.
I agree that the BCA list is not perfect. We also use other lists, regularly review results on AZB, and have a committee of players, room owners, and tour directors to review eligibility. None of it is perfect, but we do the best we can. I dare say well over 95% of the players like the format and rules. If they didn't, they wouldn't keep coming back to play. Someone is always going to be unhappy when a ruling goes against them, as seems to be the case here.
Someday maybe pool will have a unified ranking system similar to handicaps in golf. Until that time comes, we can only do so much. I try to run the best tournaments I can, listen to player concerns, and try to make it as fair as possible. Can't do more than that. The fact that we went from 12 stops last year to 20 this year says something. We aren't perfect, but we try.