Chalk. My review.

midnightpulp

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Just got in yesterday and finished watching it about an hour ago.

Better than I thought.

First off, this is a bare-bones independent production and it won't be for everyone. For the film buffs out there, think Cassavetes, Larry Clark, early Scorsese, and early Altman. It's rough, gritty, murky, but still contains some impressive low-key cinematography that recalls Scosese's "Mean Streets." Characters are often covered in shadows, backlit by neon infused cigarette smoke and thin shafts of yellow light knifing in from the outside. Nilsson and his cinematographer obviously love Film Noir, and its influence shows in virtually every frame. This "darkness" is the intended style rather than the limitations of shooting on tape. Nilsson wants a claustrophobic atmosphere, and it is indeed suffocating, but it also symbolically underscores the world these people live in.

The story concerns a young Korean pool player named T.C., who was adopted by a black hustler named Watson after he walked into Watson's pool hall one day as a kid and never left. Watson has another son named Jones, who seems to be in constant conflict with T.C., but is also trying to set up a big money match with a ranking pro, a psycho named Dorian James.

The heart of the film deals with T.C.'s dream to leave behind the cheap hustles and small stakes of hole-in-the-wall pool rooms and become a "real" player; but it also deals with his need to prove himself to his father. One key exchange has T.C. telling his father, "I ain't no money player? What have I been doing here the last 20 years?" To which Watson replies, "Taking candy from babies."

The pool world is very different in this film. It's not mythical and romantic like in "The Hustler" or glamorized like in "TCOM." These characters seem tortured by the game, especially T.C. who desperately wants to reach the next level, but might lack the necessary confidence and nerve to do so. His character is counterpointed by Dorian James, a pro who has achieved what T.C. wants, but doesn't seem to be any better off. There's also another pro player, played by a real life roadman named Chris MacDonald, who laments about the struggles of being a pool player. It's easy to read this film as an indictment of the game, the players, and the pool world at large. However, that's not Nilsson's intention.

To call this film a "cautionary tale" would be a gross misinterpretation. Yes, there's Dorian James, a troubled man who happens to be a great player, but he is hardly the center of the story, and there's no indication that the "pool world" contributed to his state of mind. Essentially, it's a tragic portrait of people who have a burning need to actualize their talent and reach their potential, but can't figure out how. Yet, either out of delusion or habit, they choose to sacrifice a life outside of the pool room and continue doing the only thing they know how to do, doomed to live out an unrecognized existence beneath shadows, smoke, and neon, dreaming of what could've been.
 
Last edited:
This review makes me want to watch this move and I've never even heard of it.... any links?

P.s; any stupid shots in the film that are going to make it unbearable, or people with fiber-glass sticks?
 
http://www.chalkfilm.org/

Not all. The pool scenes are quite realistic, even going as far as detailing strategies behind safety play. Mike Massey makes a small cameo as well. The credits listed Keith McCready and Ronnie Allen, but I didn't catch them. Tony Annigoni was a consultant on the film.

Be warned though. Compared to the slickness of Hollywood, this film is rough, not necessarily technically, I found the cinematography outstanding. The cast is comprised of members from the Tenderloin Action Group, an acting workshop open to disadvantaged people from the inner city. The actors are literally off the streets. No good looking leading men or gorgeous leading ladies in this one.

However, the final result is a very good film. Ebert gave it 3 stars, and I recommend it. I know some members on this forum hated it, and I can see why. This is a raw, realistic production that makes Pool Hall Junkies look like a Saturday Morning Cartoon. It profiles the pool world Eddie Felson had to navigate before reaching the summit of Ames.
 
midnightpulp said:
http://www.chalkfilm.org/

Not all. The pool scenes are quite realistic, even going as far as detailing strategies behind safety play. Mike Massey makes a small cameo as well. The credits listed Keith McCready and Ronnie Allen, but I didn't catch them. Tony Annigoni was a consultant on the film.

Be warned though. Compared to the slickness of Hollywood, this film is rough, not necessarily technically, I found the cinematography outstanding. The cast is comprised of members from the Tenderloin Action Group, an acting workshop open to disadvantaged people from the inner city. The actors are literally off the streets. No good looking leading men or gorgeous leading ladies in this one.

However, the final result is a very good film. Ebert gave it 3 stars, and I recommend it. I know some members on this forum hated it, and I can see why. This is a raw, realistic production that makes Pool Hall Junkies look like a Saturday Morning Cartoon. It profiles the pool world Eddie Felson had to navigate before reaching the summit of Ames.

I looked on the Ebert and Roeper website for their review and couldn't find it. It has a listing of every movie they've ever reviewed. Then I remembered that they don't give "stars" to movies. It's either thumbs up or thumbs down. Where did you see that Roger Ebert gave it 3 stars? :confused: :confused: :confused: :confused: :confused:
 
Chalk Film

Hey - Glad you liked it.

I spoke with Rob Nilsson (Director) a couple of years ago and have recently been speaking with films producers Rand Crook and Ethan Sing and looking into helping them with their 10yr anniversary relaunch (focussing on helping them across Europe and with assistance of a fellow AZ'er Kevin, also Japan).

Anybody else like it ?

I'm not sure you can still order it on chalkfilm.org - but if anyone's interested in it - I can sort out a link ?

Just PM me.

Ste.
 
Ste said:
Hey - Glad you liked it.

I spoke with Rob Nilsson (Director) a couple of years ago and have recently been speaking with films producers Rand Crook and Ethan Sing and looking into helping them with their 10yr anniversary relaunch (focussing on helping them across Europe and with assistance of a fellow AZ'er Kevin, also Japan).

Anybody else like it ?

I'm not sure you can still order it on chalkfilm.org - but if anyone's interested in it - I can sort out a link ?

Just PM me.

Ste.

Cool. This film deserves more exposure. Besides it being about pool, it's a good film in general.

I know a few posters on here didn't like it. Freddy the Beard called it a piece of "caca", lol.

It's not for everyone. Not being a film snob here, but films like these are an acquired taste. If you're used to tightly structured, glossy Hollywood fare, this film won't be for you, or it might expand your horizons. I just want to get that out there before people come back to this thread and tell me that was biggest waste of 2 hours they ever spent. It will be a different experience, but if you liked something like "Kids" you'll probably like this film.
 
George said:
Well I guess this is one of those movies you either love or hate. I hated it and I think most will feel as I do. Nothing was believable or realistic in any way. JMHO and I'm sticking to it.

I wonder if Dorians pool stick has a linen wrap.......eewwww:eek:

LOL !

:D
.
 
midnightpulp said:
Just got in yesterday and finished watching it about an hour ago.

Better than I thought.

First off, this is a bare-bones independent production and it won't be for everyone. For the film buffs out there, think Cassavetes, Larry Clark, early Scorsese, and early Altman. It's rough, gritty, murky, but still contains some impressive low-key cinematography that recalls Scosese's "Mean Streets." Characters are often covered in shadows, backlit by neon infused cigarette smoke and thin shafts of yellow light knifing in from the outside. Nilsson and his cinematographer obviously love Film Noir, and its influence shows in virtually every frame. This "darkness" is the intended style rather than the limitations of shooting on tape. Nilsson wants a claustrophobic atmosphere, and it is indeed suffocating, but it also symbolically underscores the world these people live in.

The story concerns a young Korean pool player named T.C., who was adopted by a black hustler named Watson after he walked into Watson's pool hall one day as a kid and never left. Watson has another son named Jones, who seems to be in constant conflict with T.C., but is also trying to set up a big money match with a ranking pro, a psycho named Dorian James.

The heart of the film deals with T.C.'s dream to leave behind the cheap hustles and small stakes of hole-in-the-wall pool rooms and become a "real" player; but it also deals with his need to prove himself to his father. One key exchange has T.C. telling his father, "I ain't no money player? What have I been doing here the last 20 years?" To which Watson replies, "Taking candy from babies."

The pool world is very different in this film. It's not mythical and romantic like in "The Hustler" or glamorized like in "TCOM." These characters seem tortured by the game, especially T.C. who desperately wants to reach the next level, but might lack the necessary confidence and nerve to do so. His character is counterpointed by Dorian James, a pro who has achieved what T.C. wants, but doesn't seem to be any better off. There's also another pro player, played by a real life roadman named Chris MacDonald, who laments about the struggles of being a pool player. It's easy to read this film as an indictment of the game, the players, and the pool world at large. However, that's not Nilsson's intention.

To call this film a "cautionary tale" would be a gross misinterpretation. Yes, there's Dorian James, a troubled man who happens to be a great player, but he is hardly the center of the story, and there's no indication that the "pool world" contributed to his state of mind. Essentially, it's a tragic portrait of people who have a burning need to actualize their talent and reach their potential, but can't figure out how. Yet, either out of delusion or habit, they choose to sacrifice a life outside of the pool room and continue doing the only thing they know how to do, doomed to live out an unrecognized existence beneath shadows, smoke, and neon, dreaming of what could've been.
Hey Pulp, after reading your post, I believe we have similar sensibilities. So I'm going to track down a copy to watch.
Just curious-compare "HUstler" and tcom.
 
Where else can I buy this movie Chalk? None on ebay and I dont wanna pay $22 just to watch it once. and whats this pool movie called TCOM? I honestly never heard of either. Your review of chalk makes it sound like a good movie but I watched the preview on the chalk site and it doesnt look as good as your review. :p but your review has made me want to see the movie one time. Can you make me a copy? or can anyone else? Help... :p :p I got to see the movie now.
 
Nine Ball said:
Where else can I buy this movie Chalk? None on ebay and I dont wanna pay $22 just to watch it once. and whats this pool movie called TCOM? I honestly never heard of either. Your review of chalk makes it sound like a good movie but I watched the preview on the chalk site and it doesnt look as good as your review. :p but your review has made me want to see the movie one time. Can you make me a copy? or can anyone else? Help... :p :p I got to see the movie now.
TCOM? You've most likely seen it Josh.....it starred Paul Newman and Tom Cruise ;) :D

The
Color
Of
Money

George
 
George said:
TCOM? You've most likely seen it Josh.....it starred Paul Newman and Tom Cruise ;) :D

The
Color
Of
Money

George


Oh, Your right. heh. Now what about this movie Chalk....
 
I am one that hated it

i think i got it off of bert kinisters web site, he was selling it a while back. It was so dark and badly shot i couldnt finish it. Tried selling it on ebay. took 3 times to get 12 bucks for it. Oh well some like it some say its not good. Only one way to find out.

Good luck on finding it.

PAt
 
Back
Top