Changing your stroke, is it worth it?

undefined
Egg McDogit said:
thanks for the advice, but my point is, I think people spend too much time worrying about their stroke. you can pocket balls fine with a bad stroke. My stroke is TERRIBLE...I guarantee you I have the worst stroke form of anyone on this board. It's almost 3 feet long, bridge ranges from 16-18", it's crooked as hell both horizontally and vertically, there's a little chicken wing in it, and I drop my elbow. It's hard to put in words how ugly it is - it's an ABOMINATION. But after playing seriously for a few years, I can pocket balls somewhat respectably...and in another 1-2 years I think my pocketing will be pretty strong.

If I can pocket balls with my stroke - I'm pretty sure any stroke can work given some time and practice. So if you've been playing for 10 years and want to change your stroke...my opinion is that it's not worth it. On the otherhand, you can only get so far with a bad stroke (which is pretty far)...if you're at the point where you're trying to get 1/4 ball here or there, then maybe it's something to look into.

It's going to take you a long time to get good with ANY kind of stroke.
not worth changing???? seems to me that everthing that you are doing wrong you know you are , and dont seem to care or mind. but my advice is if you are not getting better and you do care or mind :D then i suggest you experiment. whats the worst that can happen. you wont lose what you have but on the other hand , you might stumble on something and improve your game . i can say this efren, johnny, earl and many others didnt start out champions, and they are not just lucky to continue to be champions. they are doing something your not doing. yes they have talent but talent minus know how = 0... imo . your job is to figure out what they are doing. thats what they did to get good and it didnt come by spending two or three days a week in the poolroom . i dont think there is anything wrong with imitating a great players style,stroke, and the rest. i guarantee we all do it to some extent. i kinda think if the best players in the world all get really low then thats probaly one of the things that is a must. i mean personaly if i were to imitate a player and my goal was to be the best, then i would find him or her ;) . that player for me would be efren. i have used every possible grip ,stance , bridge ,cue weight and many other things there is , and if your game is not improving and you have not done much experimenting then you are not doing all it takes to be a champion, if that is indeed your goal. if not being a champion isnt your goal then this thread doesnt apply to you. i was telling jimmy the other day that i never had a good hitting cue. i hit with other peoples cues and and every now and the i would hit with someones cue that i controlled the cue ball twice as good as i did with the one i was using. but they either would not sell it or wanted to much. i never would order a cue for fear that it would not hit the way i liked and i would be stuck with it. so i usualy ended up with a cuetech or some other cue that played pretty good till you loaded it with side english then i had to get used to the deflection which was not always the same. but i got used to it so mabye i will get lucky and find a solid cuesomeday :D . ok back to the point. to be honest efren's style,grip, stance ,ect. is different and unless someone uses those same thing he does , they will never be able to do the thigs he does i promise. so my advice is to befriend efren dig in his ear and study everything about his style cue stick,brige stance ect. . cause think about this if he uses a 22oz. stick and 60inches long, and you use a 19oz. and 58inch stick and you hold the cue the way he does its not going to happen. there is a reason why he chose those specs, grip ,swing , ect. and it wasnt because he cant grip the cue cause of an accident or the strange stick he plays with now was the only stick left on the wall at the pool room in the fillipines so he had no choice. there are fundamentals that are a must to be a great player. some guys are taught by great players and some watch and figure it out. my strong oppinion is that efren has brought more advanced fundamentals to pool that will allow you to play better than players in our generation. and its not just knowledge only . the other advice is there are plenty of other champions out there that play incredible and use regular cues , swings , grips . :D .... please give feedback
 
Last edited:
Hal said:
Uh....Secrets about racking.
ok...... i think you know i knew that . now are we talking about bad racking peolpe? or good racking our opponents? seems to me the first right?
 
mark tadd said:
ok...... i think you know i knew that . now are we talking about bad racking peolpe? or good racking our opponents? seems to me the first right?

There is a player named Joe Tucker who has a book of racking secrets. He explains what is going to happen if there are gaps in different places in the rack, where to cue up and how to hit the rack to take advantage of these gaps, so if you get what looks like a bad rack it can be to your advantage because of how the balls behave when hit a certain way. There is probably a lot more secrets but that I believe is some of the general idea of it.

Wayne
 
wayne said:
There is a player named Joe Tucker who has a book of racking secrets. He explains what is going to happen if there are gaps in different places in the rack, where to cue up and how to hit the rack to take advantage of these gaps, so if you get what looks like a bad rack it can be to your advantage because of how the balls behave when hit a certain way. There is probably a lot more secrets but that I believe is some of the general idea of it.

Wayne
thanks wayne, so its a book that can work both ways right :)
 
mark tadd said:
thanks wayne, so its a book that can work both ways right :)


Yeah........... but first I think you need to learn how to actually "use" a rack to rack the balls.......(JK)...... :D
 
BRKNRUN said:
Yeah........... but first I think you need to learn how to actually "use" a rack to rack the balls.......(JK)...... :D
haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.. very funny but true :( :D but i may be able to add to his book :cool:
 
A friend of mine gave me this advice to stick to when you are experimenting with new mechanics or other aspects to the game. Ask yourself three questions and if you get a yes for each one, then it's good.

1. Is it logical? I.E. Have you found an explanation why you need to make this change? If you think you are going to fix a problem, know what is causing the problem and go directly to the source and correct it. If you don't know what's causing the problem, i.e. a twist in your stroke, you probably won't be able to fix it permanently.
2. Does it feel comfortable, or like something you can get comfortable with and adapt to with practice? If you change something in your mechanics and you start getting severe neck pain, etc, it's probably not going to work for you.
3. Does it work under pressure? I.e. you copy bustamante's stroke and you practice all day with it and you start running out. You play someone for money and you can't make a ball. You generally want to have mechanics that are pressure-proof to a certain extent. Alot of people recommend short and compact strokes. If that doesn't feel good for you, then try to find a happy medium.
 
The part of my stroke I am fixing is a chicken wing. I noticed that when I hit power draw shots I had a tendency to hit the cueball to the left. I had my wife video my stroke and it was obvious what was happening. I would compensate my chicken wing just fine on an easy stroke but when I would hit harder there was a definate inside to out motion on my hand thus putting a right to left motion on my tip. This would in turn push the cueball to the left. Thats when I decided to change my chicken wing. The reason for the change is because my game was limited to softer finesse shots. My harder shots were very unpredictable (yea I know welcome to the club). I thought that if I want to have a greater arsonal of shots I would have to fix the problem.

Now I hear from a couple that the new changes will not be available in pressure situations. My question now is why do we practice? And if I practice this new stroke and it helps my game will it not put me in less situations where I am pressured?

JV
 
oh yeah it's all wrong and I know it...then again I don't really care since it works. Here's my personal experience and why I don't think a bad stroke is that much of an issue.

Last year I looked into changing my stroke. At that time my pocketing was a a joke. I could only make maybe 60-70% of long shots and wanted to change my stroke. My thinking was that I didn't have enough talent for this game to get away with bad fundamentals. So I had a stroke lesson with a well-known instructor. He told me everything was fine (alignment, stroke, rhythm, etc), but my bridge was too long and that I should use a pendulum stroking method instead of a long loopy stroke. We watched my stroke on video. I could see in the video that my stroke was NOT straight. It did look straight from the back b/c my arm hung down straight (nowadays I chicken wing a bit).

A lot of people (stroke instructors included from my experience) incorrectly think a stroke is straight if your arm is hanging straight down (perpendicular to the ground). This isn't true. If you want a straight stroke, your arm should stroke back and forth IN LINE WITH YOUR STICK. In otherwords, if there was an overhead shot of your stroke, the point from your shoulder to elbow would be in line with the motion of your hand and your stick. I wonder if that's why Sigel stroked the way he did. Anyways, I almost NEVER see this...including the top pros. Almost always, the arm hangs down straight, but the stick is angled in or out from the body. The arm moves back and forth straight, the stick moves back and forth at an angle. So what does this mean? It means that a true straight stroke is very rare - and that almost everyone out there is playing with a crooked stroke.

So anyways, I tried out this new stroking method...I went to a 10" bridge with a pendulum stroke. It was killing my stroke rhythm and I couldn't feel my stroke. For better of worse, I said screw it. I went back to my old stroke. It's been around a year since that episode - and my pocketing has gotten a lot better. I can fire in the shots that were 60-70% before at 100mph like nothing now. Why? Time at the table.

mark tadd said:
undefined
not worth changing???? seems to me that everthing that you are doing wrong you know you are , and dont seem to care or mind. but my advice is if you are not getting better and you do care or mind :D then i suggest you experiment. whats the worst that can happen. you wont lose what you have but on the other hand , you might stumble on something and improve your
 
mark tadd said:
ok...... i think you know i knew that . now are we talking about bad racking peolpe? or good racking our opponents? seems to me the first right?
I don't KNOW what racking secrets is. THAT'S WHY I ASKED IF THE DVDS WERE ANY GOOD! :confused:
 
Johnny "V" said:
The part of my stroke I am fixing is a chicken wing. I noticed that when I hit power draw shots I had a tendency to hit the cueball to the left. I had my wife video my stroke and it was obvious what was happening. I would compensate my chicken wing just fine on an easy stroke but when I would hit harder there was a definate inside to out motion on my hand thus putting a right to left motion on my tip. This would in turn push the cueball to the left. Thats when I decided to change my chicken wing. The reason for the change is because my game was limited to softer finesse shots. My harder shots were very unpredictable (yea I know welcome to the club). I thought that if I want to have a greater arsonal of shots I would have to fix the problem.

Now I hear from a couple that the new changes will not be available in pressure situations. My question now is why do we practice? And if I practice this new stroke and it helps my game will it not put me in less situations where I am pressured?

JV

I'm talking about finding a stroke that is pressure proof to an extent, thats all.
 
Back
Top