All three are ok to use, but not for every application. Most of the time the better tables come with a wood strip that can be shaved to fit the joint,or it already is. Plastic strips are similar to wood but cant be worked easily as wood can. Some are hollow, some are solid.
The rubber ones require using a different technique to install them, they need to be snug or they wont work/look very good.
Wood is easiest to work with both installing and shaping , I keep a set in my truck ,just in case I break one on a re-cloth.
I would re-use any of them if they fit ok.