I would just order new from classic billiards. I took mine off and began the dent removal and sanding and polishing route....I probably have 500 hours of time in my life on my buffing wheels and i decided it just wasnt worth it. If you look closely you can see the brads go in at an angle all in the same direction - take a small punch and start tapping the end of the trim in the direction the brads were shot in. After you get a couple of inches pushed out the groove on the other end put the rail in a vice and you can grab the trim and pull it on out the groove - you are not pulling it out of groove perpendicular but pulling it in direction of groove - comes out easy!