Yes, some things have that extra something that speak and connect with certain people. This is as true with certain musical instruments as it is with cues, although it's hard to define, it's real.
I heard Chohan in a podcast from a year or so ago, where the host was asking him about how amazing his game had been during a particular stretch. He responded by saying something like, the SW cue I was using at the time allowed me to do anything, etc.
Start about the 3 minute mark on this video for an example till the 8th minute mark.
Wood is a living thing, and it's not all equal. Sometimes you come across a guitar, cue, shaft, etc. where it calls to you, and yes, it seems magical.