Please explain this to me

Since this is my first post on this forum, a little bio is left at the bottom (for your amusement).

As analogies go: I tend to think of pool in the same way I think of golf (and not just how I learned to swing a the golf ball).

When I started to play golf, I just wanted to play. I started out near 100 strokes per round, not including the mulligans,.... loosing 5-10 balls per round and over 5-6 years had brought this down to a disgusting 90-ish sometimes even including the mulligans,... still loosing 4-7 balls per round. Never broke 90 obeying the stroke counting rules.

Then I found myself in a job working for someone I really despised. It was so stressful that I had to hit something every day; hard and often. I choose golf balls to stay out of jail :). I ended up hitting 200 golf balls a day every single day of the week/month/year for over 2 years playing on a golf course only very occasionally. I was not just pounding balls, I was working in the sand, rough, hard-pan, putting,... During this period of time, I wore out two sets of Titlest clubs--not the shafts (although I did go through 4 sets of shafts), the faces of the clubs.

When I found myself back on the golf course, that 90 had suddenly become 76-80, hardly ever missing the fairway, hitting the sand, or getting myself in trouble.

Pool is the same way, if you want to get better, practice more often than you play.

Yet, billiards parlors (n.e. pool halls) need a regular clientele so they can stay in business and allow the non-table owning players to enjoy playing pool. This is where the leagues come in. In order for the leagues to be profitable to the establishments, then need a number of weekly clients, and making it fun is a lot more conductive to clients showing up than making it a "learning" experience. To paraphrase Churchill:: Handicapping is worst form of evening out the 'slate', excepting for all the rest.

Bio: Me:: My father and 3 of his buddies bought all the pool tables of a hall that was going out of business back when I was in high school. So I played 3-5 hours a day for 3 years in HS, then another 3-6 hours a day for 6 years in the frat house while in College, and then did not play pool for 35 years.

I picked pool up a couple of years ago when we moved to an urban setting and I was within walking distance of a bar with a pool table. Its taken 2 complete years playing almost daily, and I am still no where close to where I was "way back when" and it likely that I never will be, physically. I do not participate in leagues (at this point in time) but have several friends that have told me I would be a strong 5 or a week 6 on the APA scale.
 
I don't get the complaints....I mean, tourneys want participants. If you have to play someone going to 4 to your 7, and will lose that race on a consistant basis, either you aren't a 7 or he's not a 4. I don't hear the same complaints from players giving up the 8 (or whatever) in a money game. If you win 75% time giving the 8 - adjust; unless the guy you're beating refuses. Same with tourneys....sometimes someone will come in and the person running the tourney doesn't know what to rank the player, but if he plays in it for a couple of weeks it should be pretty easy to rate him correctly....big deal, you lose to someone going to 4 who should be going to 6 - it happens. If it happens EVERY week, then the guy running the tourney isn't doing his job, and will lose participants (he doesn't want that any more than you do).

I want to play over my head to win, so, I'd rather try to outrun a situation than be in the dominate position all the time.
 
handicapped games

I've been on both sides of the handicap issue. One tournament I entered I had to get to 6 before the opponent got to 2....I broke and ran the first rack to the eight, missed my shape, made the eight but got worse on the nine. So I missed the nine, leaving it in the jaws, and he was on the hill. In another tournament, I had to reach 3 before Mr. McCready reached 5. I combo'd the 9 twice and won, so now I can tell my grandkids I beat a pro once. (LOL) I agree with those who say without the handicap, you won't have a tournament for long. When I was a bowler, I enjoyed handicapped leagues. I had fun, even with the sandbaggers. Once, a friend asked me to join his team in a Scratch League. I didn't have much fun there, because if you missed a spare, no one would talk to you. Everyone was so dead serious.
I went back to handicapped leagues. I guess all I'm saying is, I don't care if I can't get as good as Keith McCready, I just want to enjoy the game.
 
I've been playing for 25+ years now and invested alot of time and money.

So someone explain to me again why a guy that picked up a cue 2 months ago should be handicapped so that the match is equal?

Don't get me wrong I love the game of pool and new people playing is a
good thing and I will help anyone that asks.

But this is killing the game of pool....I quote

"But if I practice the director will move me up"
"you know what a 5 is....its a smart 7"
"why should I play 5 or 10 dollars in tourney if I have no chance"

I've played in tournements straight races to 4 or 7 where I get matched up with a guy that if we were to gamble would give me the last 2. Win or lose in a straight up set I'm fine with that becuse we both had the same chance to win.

If I lose the next day I come in pissed and practice harder... if win I come in the next day happy practice harder

But when a two handicapp on has to make 1 ball to my 300 or win 1 game to my 7 I have a problem with that.

Is it just me...or should I call Dr. Phil or wait for Obama to bail ME out.

I hear you. But first of all, if a guy is a 5 and should be a 7, guaranteed he didn't just pick up a cue two months ago.

And second, a guy who just picked up a cuestick two months ago, you should be able to beat giving him 9 games going to 10. You just have to play differently. I guarantee you that if you lose that set it's because you made a mistake. Or he slopped in a 9-ball break or something. For someone who just picked up a cue 2 months ago, that's a pretty good shot.

I was listening to a guy from the FAA talk about the crash in the hudson river. He said that in crash evacuation simulations when they give incentives to people to be first off the plane, (i.e. the first 10 people off the plane get $100) that the same 10 people get off the plane first...NO MATTER WHERE THEY WERE SEATED.

I think pool tournaments are the same. I think the players who win, will win no matter what their handicap is and the players who lose, will lose no matter what their handicap is.

Personally, I feel like I have a better chance to win a handicapped tournament where I have to give weight to EVERYONE than I do an open tournament with the same players. Just from the psychological edge that the handicap gives me. That belief has probably helped me win many, many tournaments that I wasn't 'supposed to.'

Playing a guy you don't know even, and he breaks and runs the first game. You think, no problem, I can do that too.

Now, if you're playing a guy you don't know, and he's giving you 2 games going to 7 and he breaks and runs the first rack, you start to think, uh-oh, half my handicap is wiped out. Then if he wins the next game, you think "crap, now it's even..."

I've noticed that if the player giving up games on the wire gets to even, they ALMOST NEVER lose from there.

In scratch tournaments, however, guys come from behind all the time.

So, the key to playing against people with or without handicaps is keeping your mental game strong. If you have to give up weight, the secret is in crushing the other player as quickly as possible, usually they will give up and unless you make a really dramatic mistake, they will keep finding ways to lose.

If you are getting weight, never, never, never, never give up. And if it looks hopeless, never, ever, ever give up. And remember, if you can win the first couple of games, then hopefully your opponent is someone who hates handicap systems. Because once they get down 3-0 they will usually already have their excuses running in their head and will go ahead and lose to you just to prove how unfair handicap systems are.

If you have a problem winning handicap matches, I can almost guarantee that it's your mental game that needs work.

~rc
 
Back
Top