I prefer to have some climb in the taper also, and keep checking with My calipers to make sure I'm keeping with that gradual climb. Basically what I would do is pull that taper back to make the transition as smooth as possible. after I'm done It may look like a straight taper to some with the naked eye, but put the calipers to It and It reflects the climb I try to leave in the shaft. I want to make the shaft more comfortable, but as someone already mentioned I try not to beat too much of the taper down, creating a whippy shaft in the process.
If They had something different in mind, A person could be more specific in explaining what they want I guess, but Your description would probably be enough to go on for most people. I agree though, each shaft has a life of their own, so even 2 identical taper shafts could produce different feels. that's just the nature of maple or alot of wood types in general.
Greg