tpdtom said:
I saw it the same way as 3andstop had it, with the only exception being not to get in the trees on the 5 Ball.
For the latter pattern of Ray's bumping the 11 Ball , I have a concern and a question. Is the difficulty worth the result ? Is there anything wrong with the Seven as a break ball ?
Good discussion...Tom
To answer your first question... yes. For 2 reasons. First, that shot is not difficult. It's almost a dead-center ball hit with maybe a little outside. Therefore, I don't see a risk in making the 5 and attempting to bump up the 11. I would feel about 90-95% confident in making this shot.
Second, even if I don't hit the 11 in a good way, I still have the 4, 7, and 10 as insurance balls (with the 7 being the back-up break out ball). So this lowers the risk of this shot even more. When you combine these 2 factors, this really isn't that risky of a shot as there is minimal collateral damage that can be done.
Risk assessment is vital to any good pool game and especially so in 14.1. If there is a possibility to improve the layout of the table without adversely affecting neighboring balls, or the layout in general, then a player should take the shot (assuming they are confident they can execute it). I am by no means an expert or a pro, but this is how I've been taught the game and I see the reason and logic behind it. When you have the chance to "improve" the layout of the table... do it.
As to your second question, I believe the 7 ball is not a good break out ball. It will work if necessary, but it is certainly not the ideal break out ball for a couple of reasons. The most obvious reason is that you will more than likely not get a good breakout because you will just be clipping the corner ball. Hitting the corner ball only generally does not create a great spread (of course there are exceptions to this rule). Another reason is cue ball control after the break out. Normally, as a general rule, you would like to have your cue ball come back out to the center of the table (or in the area) after the breakout shot. On the 7, more than likely, the cue ball would move toward the side rail or toward the corner pocket thus limiting your options after the breakout.
Again, these are just my thoughts and as I stated I am by no means an expert. But these are just general rules of 14.1 that I've either been taught or have discovered on my own. Hope this answers your question.
Ray