I have an early Tad I’d like to get refinished but I can’t stand the thought of losing the wrap.
So I had the exact situation many years ago.
I bought a Tad brand new and played with it everyday for about 4 years. The wrap was 12/10 good. The finish was worn through and I didn’t want the wood to get stained up from chalk/dirt.
Dropped the cue off with Jerry Franklin and asked if he would do refinish and “save the wrap”.
. Please save the wrap Jerry. He said he wasn’t sure if he could but he’d do his best. Of course that was good enough for me.
When I was leaving the shop away he said again “I’m not 100% certain I can save the wrap”. Jerry was a very good friend so I replied “ok great! Save it anyways” winked and left. (I wasn’t being a dick as it was said in way you can poke at a friend a bit”.
Couple weeks later I get the call from Jerry that my cue was done. Yay
I made my way over to his shop and he proudly handed me the cue. With Tads wrap still on it. I was so happy. I told Jerry the truth “there was never a doubt”. Jerry was such a great person/friend.
I went back to playing full time with that Tad and a couple months later Jerry passed away.
There wasn’t a nick, dent or ding on it when Jerry passed. It was a mint butt with dirty shafts from years of play.
I still have that cue. I will always have that cue and while I did retire it when Jerry passed as a memory of Jerry I never intended on norm playing with it. So it’s been used some since then, it’s in a case I got in 1985 and is one of my most cherished cues.
So yes the wrap can be saved, if who’s doing the work cares enough.
I don’t have a pic of it sorry.
Best
Fatboy