I'm sure there are many of us that would love to own a blem cue from a cue-maker we admire. You see this all the time with other merchandise and sporting goods where the item is sold "as is" without any warranty but the flaw is pointed out in the merchandise up for sale. There's lots of great bargains that can sometimes be found.....if you could get a Louie Vitton Purse on sale at 50% off because the zipper was sewn uneven or the straps were a slightly different color shade, it's still a great present to get someone.
When things are manufactured for sale to the public at large, it's expected there will be some product rejects, even if it only involved a misprinted label on the garment or the color shade was different, etc. But some things are not worth releasing, especially when there's a limited number of items. Aside from a pool cue, another example is paintings. I think there will be very few painters that would put one of their works up for sale at a discount because it had a flaw in the canvas, or the paint colors were unevenly matched or the size proportions of the scene were incongruous to what the painter had in mind........Nope, those paintings get destroyed or never seen until the artist dies. There's too much pride and reputation involved and maybe some of that rubs off on cue-makers. I know there are curios, currency, newspapers, artifacts that can have a mistake which renders them the most rare of rare types of its kind....like a misprinted Treasury Note.......but that's not the norm.....but it might apply to cues.....I dunno?
Look, it's one thing to say you're playing with a cue because the points & veneers were off or the inlays didn't align evenly but the cue still plays as well as any you ever made, That's a cue you might also consider passing along to someone that's a close acquaintance and definitely one you'd play with but it's not one you want out on the streets representing your cue-making. Nope, I tend to think that when you decided to become a cue-maker, you made a contract with yourself to be the best cue-maker you can be....and it's a contract that's hard to ignore when the cue-maker is honest and truthful with himself, as much as with his customers. I don't foresee pool cue building mishaps eventually contributing to any market evolution in the future for "blemished cues for sale".
Thanks for the replies.....I see some folks expressing a definite preference which is what I was imagining would be the case.
Matt B.