Meucci's
I agree, the old Meucci's, 70/early 80's didn't hit bad. Lot of times it is the way you have come up in the sport. Some guys start with a brand of cue, get used to it, and stick with it for years and years. Some people start with a soft tip, and become sold on them. We develop habits, and we tend to stick with what is comfortable for us.
30 years ago, I thought Joss was one of the very best cues out there, but I do not like the Joss's today, especially the < $500 ones. They hit like a steel rod with no feel at all, probably because of the 13.25mm shafts on them.
It's hard for people to break out of their habits, unless they are absolutely convinced they are going to something better. But, then, even with something better, you have to take a step backwards before going forwards.
Personally, I don't think you can really judge a cue completely unless you play with it for 3 weeks minimum. Kind of like cars, you can test drive them, but to find out everything about them takes awhile.
How I test cues:
1) Draw shots, long and short.
2) Force Spin shots.
3) 3 and 4 rail english shots.
4) Important test: object ball 1/2 table away.
Draw back 1-2".
Go forward 1-2".
5) cut shot with inside english then going 3 rails for shape.
6) Off the end rail shots with object ball down table almost straight.
You have to test for versitility as well as power in getting shape.